Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
BRITAIN’S BREXIT MINISTER David Davis has come under fire after admitting to MPs that the government has made no official assessment of the impact of Brexit on various sectors of the UK economy.
Davis was called before the House of Commons Brexit committee after MPs were dissatisfied with the “sectoral analysis” provided to the committee by the government.
He told the committee that “he wasn’t a fan of economic models because they have all proven wrong”, citing the 2008 economic crisis as an example of their inability to model “paradigm” changes.
The government initially said it would provide the committee with an 850-page assessment of Brexit’s impact on 58 economic sectors.
However, Davis said the studies were merely “sectoral analyses”, which did not predict the effects of leaving the EU.
When asked about whether there were impact assessments completed on the financial services, automotive and aerospace, Davis said: “I think the answer is going to be no for all of them.”
“You don’t need to do an impact assessment, a formal impact assessment to understand that if there is a regulatory hurdle between our producers and a market that it will have an impact, it all has an effort,” David told MPs.
“The assessment of that effect, I think I have said it to you before, is not as straightforward as people imagine.
“I am not a fan of economic models because they have all proven wrong.”
The fact that no impact studies had been for aviation, automobiles and financial services drew derision.
Commission chair Hilary Benn said: ”On the most fundamental change that we are facing as a country you’ve just told us that the government hasn’t undertaken any impact assessments at all.”
Davis said there would be such studies “at some stage” when Brexit negotiations move on to the second phase, but other lawmakers also hit out.
“Davis is either grossly incompetent or someone who struggles with the truth and treats MPs with contempt,” said Green Party co-leader Caroline Lucas.
“Either way, he should be out of his job.”
Former Liberal Democrat leader Tim Farron also called for Davis to step down, writing on Twitter that under his leadership “the Brexit department has turned incompetence into an art form.”
MPs have also approached House of Commons speaker John Bercow about the possibility of a contempt motion against Davis, but the move appears unlikely after the committee voted it down by 11 members to eight.
With reporting by AFP.
Welcome!
Welcome your are valued and respected for your brave move.
Good man Nasir welcome to Ireland,
But never abandon your own people.
Keep their problems in the limelight
It is people like this we need to enrich our society, unfortunately economic migrants don’t stop to think about the damage they are causing to genuine asylum seekers……….
@Sean Higgins: And the difference between the two is…do you know?
@Maxwell Eddizon: No…¡
@Maxwell Eddizon:
Asylum Seeker
a person who has left their home country as a political refugee and is seeking asylum in another.
Economic Migrant:
a person who enters another country in search of work.
@Sean Higgins: And every irish person who has emigrated since the 20th century has been an economic migrant.
@Sean Higgins: Wrong. An economic migrant comes to improve his living standards…
@Ciara Ni Mhurchu: fair enough but how many claimed asylum in the countries they moved to?
@Maxwell Eddizon: does the word economic not give it away, anyway I’d rather not get into a debate with a lad who answers his own questions, see above………..
@Sean Higgins: 11.5¿
@Maxwell Eddizon: sure didnt he say he was genuine ,is that not enough for you
@Sean Higgins: No debate – just Google it and you’ll quickly see I’m correct!
@Maxwell Eddizon: does searching for work not come under the heading of improving living standards?
@Sean Higgins: Who then would clean hotel rooms, serve food in mcdonalds and restaurants or picking mushrooms in cold temperatures, etc…there are thousands of economic migranst from eastern Europe who work really hard to improve their living standards. Unfortunately EU is not about the same standards for every states. If some of irish people are desperate for work, in my country we have the highest production of cars in Europe. The industry is booming. Hovewer, in Germany factory workers get around 8,5 eur per hour. In my country people can earn from 3-5 eur per hour, with nights and overtime even over 1000 eur. We have still high unemployment in many regions in the country. But we have very good weather, cheaper alcohol and cigarrets,but groceries, clothes and electronics cost as much as in Ireland and yes, we pay for usage of water (by the way owned by French). Welcome in an EU
@Ciara Ni Mhurchu: True.
@Sean Higgins: They cannot claim asylum if they are not being persecuted inn their home country. Are you aware of Irish citizens fleeing their country due to persecution?
Sorry for every imperfection in my written English ;-) Particles in my native language don’t exist. I just wanted to add I wish there would be more tourists from the west in my country and in all eastern Europe. It would help our tourism and economy in general. But this is a bit utopian idea. Better to keep emigrating or staying making cars for 480-700eur, working in lidl or cleaning rooms for 400eur or in case of having a degree to move to a capital city, where earning 600-1200eur is much better while paying rent from 200-500eur per month and higher. I just correct our minimum wage per hour is 2,5eur. If you want to buy a property the average price per meter square is 1475eur. In the capital city, it could be even more than 3000 eur per meter square. According the latest statistics average cost of diesel: 0,96 (Switzerland), 1.08 (Poland), 1,22 (Ireland), 1,18 (my home country), 1,10 (Austria). Cost of unleaded 95: 0,95 (Switzerland), 1,10 (Poland), 1,33 (Ireland), 1,35 (my home country) and 1,05 our richer neighbour Austria. The highest fuel prices are recorded in the Norway, Italy, France and Portugal. And I know Ireland has the fourth most expensive electricity cost.
@Sean Higgins: “Enriched” No thanks sound likes forced multiculturism . All of Africa or the world can head for Europe as refugees .
@Sean Higgins: economic migrants can simply mean someone who moves to a different country to avail of its social benefits too.
@Ciara Ni Mhurchu: Every person who emigrated from Ireland many years ago helped to build that Country they went to. That is why they were welcomed and yes there are migrants who work in this Country now and that is good. What about the people who come here and want to do nothing? It is mostly the Government’s fault as there’s no planning for the Migrant intake in other Wordsl they are feeding from the one breakfast bowl.
Nasir Great to have you here and looking forward to hear your opinions and culture
@Thee Orson Welles: Please publish YOUR name, and stand over your opinions, you anonymous coward.
@Thee Orson Welles: well SAID
He studied irish literature and is learning English. Well done.
Céad míle fáilte, sir!
Welcome .Try the stew Its delightful
@the druid: Coddle – proof that the eyes are a key part of the enjoyment of eating – coddle is a fantastic winter dish, but looks awful!
@the druid: had it at the Gravediggers in Glasnevin last week, can’t wait to go back for more.
Clearly a talented man we need to stop keeping talented people in dp when clearly they have a lot to contribute. Guys like this should just be given irish passport I don’t see any reason why not.
@Bhiniáimin Ó Beith: he’s still needs to go through the process first .. can’t be just handing out an Irish passport on the grounds that he seems a great man .
@Siobhán Ni Mhurchú: we need a few though
Lovely to see new faces to Ireland that will enrich our culture. It is wonderful to see a talented Journalist and Artist finding new purpose and of course safety and being able to express his opinions without fear and punishment ….You are so welcome sir, many thanks for sharing your story and lovely to see x
Wonderful little stories Luke these are meant to keep us all quiet, I’m sure this guy is a genuine person. My issue is the number of people coming in, I fear nobody has ran the numbers, we should not keep taking in people until we can sort out our own people. It’s not fair on people coming in, where do these people live? How do we feed, cloth them? Is there room in schools for children? Can health service cope? If we are going to help people, let’s help them properly. Liberal social justice warriors just want to show how good and noble they are. What about after the fact?!
Welcome Nasir. Keep writing about your country, the Sudan crisis has never really gotten the media attention it deserves. Never ever give in to clerical bullies like the NIF.
Welcome Nasir. I hope Ireland provides you and your family with s safe environment where you can all grow and flourish.
Great to hear a good sided story for a change, a land of a thousand welcomes to all peaceful law abiding people…
@Paul Maher: Muppet!
Failte roimh dhearthair
Welcome sir!
I have 5 of his paintings and we sponsored his art supplies by bartering… a very nice and genuine man
You are most welcome to our country!
Poor man ending up Longford.
Really nice story. Hope you embrace and lead as an example of 1 mans passion for what he does. Fair fooks.
Welcome Nasir! Good to have you here
Welcome Nasir, good hard working people are always welcome !
You are very welcome here and I hope your asylum case is processed quickly and that you and your family are happy in Ireland. Cead Mile Failte!
have your say