Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
WOULD A HAN Solo who’s not Harrison Ford be the same sarcastic hero every “Star Wars” fan cherishes?
What would “Lord of the Rings” look like with Nicolas Cage in one of the main roles?
Characters become iconic thanks in large part to the actors who bring them to life, and it’s often hard to imagine anyone else in the role after the fact.
But some actors are fired from a role, some leave because of other commitments, and some just don’t accept the offer.
When an offer is first presented, it can be hard to see how successful a film might become. Some actors regret turning down a project, but others, like Jack Nicholson, know that it can be the right choice, no matter how popular or critically adored the film might become.
Here are 30 iconic characters that were almost played by different actors:
Played by: Mark Wahlberg
After watching him in “The Basketball Diaries,” Paul Thomas Anderson wanted DiCaprio to star in “Boogie Nights.” DiCaprio turned it down to appear in “Titanic,” but recommended his friend and “Basketball Diaries” costar Mark Wahlberg.
DiCaprio told GQ in 2008 that he regretted turning down the role. “‘Boogie Nights’ is a movie I loved and I wish I would’ve done.” When asked if he would reverse his decision if he could, DiCaprio said, “I’m not saying I would have. But it would have been a different direction, career-wise. I think they’re both great and wish I could have done them both.”
DiCaprio was also offered $20 million by Lionsgate to portray crazed serial killer Patrick Bateman in “American Psycho,” even though director Mary Harron wanted Christian Bale in the role. She was replaced by director Oliver Stone, but DiCaprio and Stone couldn’t agree on a creative direction, so DiCaprio left to film “The Beach.” Harron returned to the project and Bale was cast.
Played by: Harrison Ford
During the “An Evening with Pacino” event in 2013, the actor revealed that he could have played the iconic role of Han Solo in the “Star Wars” franchise.
“It was mine for the taking, but I didn’t understand the script,” he said.
He also revealed that he turned down roles in “Apocalypse Now” and “Pretty Woman,” eventually played by Marlon Brando and Richard Gere, respectively.
Played by: Audrey Hepburn
Truman Capote, the author of “Breakfast at Tiffany’s,” wanted Marilyn Monroe to play Holly, but Monroe turned it down because she was warned that portraying Holly might be bad for her image.
Played by: Brad Pitt
Early screenplays of the David Fincher film were written with Denzel Washington in mind. In a 2012 interview with GQ, the actor revealed that he regretted not accepting the role. Washington also said that he regrets turning down the lead in “Michael Clayton,” which was later played by George Clooney and earned the actor an Oscar nomination.
Played by: Harrison Ford
After watching Ford in “Star Wars,” director Steven Spielberg wanted Ford to play Indiana Jones, but George Lucas, who served as an executive producer for “Raiders of the Lost Ark,” didn’t want to cast Ford in another of his projects.
Selleck was chosen to play Jones, but had to drop out because of his contractual obligations for ”Magnum, P.I.,” so Lucas relented and Ford was cast.
Played by: Sam Neill
Director Steven Spielberg and Ford had worked together for the “Indiana Jones” films, but when Spielberg offered the role of Dr. Alan Grant to Ford, he declined.
Played by: Matthew Broderick
Johnny Depp was reportedly being considered to play Ferris, a high schooler who feigns an illness to skip school and hang out in Chicago with his friends, but director John Hughes has claimed that he wrote the script with Broderick in mind.
Other actors, including Jim Carrey and Tom Cruise, were also considered.
Played by: Halle Berry
Angela Bassett turned down the role of Leticia in “Monster’s Ball” because she found the part stereotypical and demeaning. She told Newsweek, “I wasn’t going to be a prostitute [though the role is not literally that of a prostitute] on film. I couldn’t do that because it’s such a stereotype about black women and sexuality.”
Berry became the first African-American actress to win an Oscar for Best Actress for her role in the film.
Played by: Jack Nicholson
Though the part of Garrett Breedlove in “Terms of Endearment” was written for Reynolds, he turned it down. Nicholson ended up winning a Best Supporting Actor Oscar for the role. Reynolds, who has never won an Oscar, told Business Insider that it’s the acting decision he regrets the most.
“I regret that one most of all because it was a real acting part,” he said. “I wish I would have done it, and thinking back now, it was really a stupid decision, but I made a lot of stupid decisions in that period. It must have been my stupid period.”
He also turned down the opportunities to play the first American James Bond and Han Solo.
Played by: Viggo Mortensen
In an interview with Newsweek, Nicolas Cage revealed that he turned down the role of Aragorn in “The Lord of the Rings” series because of the commitment involved.
“There were different things going on in my life at the time that precluded me from being able to travel and be away from home for three years,” he said.
But he also added that he doesn’t regret it because he gets to enjoy the series as a fan.
Played by: Ian McKellen
Even though he was a fan of the series by J.R.R. Tolkien, Plummer turned down the role of Gandalf. In an appearance on “Conan,” the actor said that he wasn’t exactly sure why he turned it down, but it sounds like the commitment was too much at the time.
“I thought there are other countries I’d like to visit before I croak,” he said.
Sean Connery also reportedly turned the role down because he didn’t understand “The Lord of the Rings” series or script.
Played by: Sandra Bullock
Julia Roberts reportedly didn’t have interest in the script when she received it. Her passing led to Bullock taking the part — after some initial reservations. She ended up taking home the Oscar for Best Actress.
Played by: Tom Hanks
John Travolta reportedly turned down the titular role in “Forrest Gump” and later regretted the decision. Chevy Chase and Bill Murray both turned down the part as well. Hanks won his second Best Actor Oscar for his portrayal.
Played by: Tom Cruise
Imagine Tom Hanks shouting “Show me the money!” because that almost happened. Director Cameron Crowe wrote the script with Hanks in mind for the lead role, but he was busy directing his first feature film, “That Thing You Do!” and the part went to Cruise instead.
Played by: Sarah Jessica Parker
Carrie Bradshaw taught fans about fashion and romance over the course of six seasons and two feature films, but Sarah Jessica Parker almost didn’t play “Sex and the City’s” narrator. “Desperate Housewives’” Dana Delany revealed that she passed on the part during an appearance on “Today.”
Played by: Al Pacino
Al Pacino earned two Academy Award nominations for his portrayal of mob boss Michael Corleone in “The Godfather” films, but Jack Nicholson was first offered the part. In an interview with Movieline, the actor said that he passed because “back then I believed that Indians should play Indians and Italians should play Italians.”
Played by: Whoopi Goldberg
After the character was originally written for Bette Midler, she ended up not accepting it because she worried that her fans wouldn’t want to see her playing a nun.
Played by: Jon Hamm
The suave ad man played flawlessly by Jon Hamm was almost played by Thomas Jane. Hamm told Marc Maron that AMC wanted Jane on the show, but the network was told that he “does not do television.” Jane went on to star in HBO’s “Hung,” another TV series.
Played by: Jennifer Lawrence
Harvey Weinstein told Howard Stern that Anne Hathaway was his choice for “Silver Linings Playbook”: ”She’s marvelous and wonderful, and she was my choice. I love her … We had Annie and then we had Mark [Wahlberg], and then whatever happened happened.”
He also added that director David O. Russell and Hathaway disagreed about a few things.
“David and Anne had some creative differences … They didn’t see eye-to-eye,” he said.
Donna Gigliotti told Deadline that scheduling conflicts with Hathaway’s commitment to “The Dark Knight Rises” prohibited her from doing the film. Wahlberg also had to drop out because of another commitment.
Played by: Bryan Cranston
“Breaking Bad” creator Vince Gilligan wanted Cranston to play Walter White, the chemistry teacher turned meth maker, but executives at AMC were gunning for a film star. Matthew Broderick, of “Ferris Bueller” fame, was thrown out as an option, but he passed.
John Cusack was also reportedly considered.
Played by: Kevin Bacon
Tom Cruise impressed the casting directors for “Footloose” with his moves in “Risky Business,” but because of his involvement with “All the Right Moves,” he couldn’t do the film.
Rob Lowe also auditioned three times for the part, but an injury prevented him from taking the gig.
Played by: Steve Carell
It’s hard to imagine anyone but Carell portraying the awkwardly endearing regional manager of Dunder Mifflin, but Kevin Reilly, then the president of NBC, recommended Paul Giamatti for the role. He passed and Carell’s career took off.
Played by: Julia Roberts
Molly Ringwald had looked at an early script for “Pretty Woman” and turned it down. In a Reddit AMA, the actress said that she doesn’t regret it.
“Julia Roberts is what makes that movie. It was her part. Every actor hopes for a part that lets them shine like that,” she said.
Other actresses who also turned down the role include Michelle Pfeiffer and Daryl Hannah.
Played by: James Gandolfini
After portraying Henry Hill in Martin Scorsese’s “Goodfellas,” Liotta was a top choice to play Tony Soprano in HBO’s “The Sopranos.” He wanted to focus on his film career instead of TV, so he turned it down.
Played by: John Travolta
The studio wanted Henry Winkler, known for his role as Fonzie on “Happy Days,” as Danny, leader of the T-Birds. The characters of Fonzie and Danny were similar, and Winkler was wary of being typecast, so he passed.
Played by: Jamie Foxx
Smith spent hours talking about the film with director Quentin Tarantino, but ultimately did not accept the role because of creative differences. He told The Hollywood Reporter, “To me, it’s as perfect a story as you could ever want: a guy that learns how to kill to retrieve his wife that has been taken as a slave. That idea is perfect. And it was just that Quentin and I couldn’t see” eye-to-eye.
Smith wanted it to be about love, not vengeance.
“We can’t look at what happens in Paris [the terrorist attacks] and want to f— somebody up for that,” he said. “Violence begets violence. I just couldn’t connect to violence being the answer. Love had to be the answer.”
Smith also turned down the role of Neo (Keanu Reeves) in “The Matrix.”
Played by: Michael J. Fox
Michael J. Fox was the first choice to play Marty, but he was busy filming “Family Ties,” so director Robert Zemeckis cast Eric Stoltz, but after five weeks of filming, Zemeckis made the decision to recast.
“Eric is a really good actor, and I made the decision to put him in the movie, but it turned out that his instincts and the type of the comedy [of] the film we were doing weren’t really gelling,” he said.
Fox’s schedule opened up, and he was able to take on the part.
Played by: Chris Noth
Darren Star, creator of “Sex and the City,” originally envisioned Alex Baldwin as Mr. Big, Carrie’s central relationship through the show’s six seasons and two films, until he met Chris Noth.
“I don’t really watch ‘Law & Order,’ but I met with Chris Noth and thought he was perfect,” Star told Entertainment Weekly. “I remember the first table read, how good he was.”
Played by: Daniel Craig
Hugh Jackman revealed that he was asked to play the iconic 007 years ago, but declined because of his role as Wolverine in the “X-Men” films, specifically “X-Men 2″ at that time. Daniel Craig took over from Pierce Brosnan following 2002′s “Die Another Day.” Jackman saysthat he would now “seriously consider” playing Bond.
Played by: Sabrina Le Beauf
Before she was a Grammy-winning artist, Houston was cast as the oldest daughter on “The Cosby Show,” but she decided not to sign the contract. According to director Jay Sandrich, Houston wanted to focus on her singing career.
“So we gather in this room and there are kids from New York and Los Angeles and they are all signing their contracts, and this girl who we brought from New York said, ‘I can’t sign this contract.’ And I said ‘Why?’ She said, ‘Well, I want to be a singer … I can’t be in every show … I have to be able to tour.”
She didn’t have a recording contract and she had never toured, but she knew she was destined for a music career. She wasn’t wrong.
Isnt god wonderful….
No….The universe is wonderful.
Your obviously more religous than scientific otherwise you would know your so called God did not create the Universe. Or this World for that matter.
I think there was a slight hint of sarcasm in James’s comment which you all missed
Nice work putting the caption over the actual object in the image…
Erhhhhhh…….they didn’t. Its above the word “at” in the caption right on the edge of the outer ring.
Infinitesmily grand!
Is that we’re the little bo***x Fitzpatrick comes from????
The world is flat, one god created all this and we don’t know who created him/her/it?
I’ve got your ring and new moon right here.
God
Invisible pink unicorn
SCIENCE SHOWS THAT THE UNIVERSE CANNOT BE ETERNAL because it could not have sustained itself eternally due to the law of entropy (increasing net energy decay, even in an open system). Einstein showed that space, matter, and time all are physical and all had a beginning. Space even produces particles because it’s actually something, not nothing. Even time had a beginning! Time is not eternal.
The law of entropy doesn’t allow the universe to be eternal. If the universe were eternal, everything, including time (which modern science has shown is as physical as mass and space), would have become totally entropied by now and the entire universe would have ended in a uniform heat death a long, long time ago. The fact that this hasn’t happened already is powerful evidence for a beginning to the universe.
Popular atheistic scientist Stephen Hawking admits that the universe had a beginning and came from nothing but he believes that nothing became something by a natural process yet to be discovered. That’s not rational thinking at all, and it also would be making the effect greater than its cause to say that nothing created something. The beginning had to be of supernatural origin because natural laws and processes do not have the ability to bring something into existence from nothing. What about the Higgs boson (the so-called “God Particle”)? The Higgs boson does not create mass from nothing, but rather it converts energy into mass. Einstein showed that all matter is some form of energy.
The supernatural cannot be proved by science but science points to a supernatural intelligence and power for the origin and order of the universe. Where did God come from? Obviously, unlike the universe, God’s nature doesn’t require a beginning.
EXPLAINING HOW AN AIRPLANE WORKS doesn’t mean no one made the airplane. Explaining how life or the universe works doesn’t mean there was no Maker behind them. Natural laws may explain how the order in the universe works and operates, but mere undirected natural laws cannot explain the origin of that order. Once you have a complete and living cell then the genetic code and biological machinery exist to direct the formation of more cells, but how could life or the cell have naturally originated when no directing code and mechanisms existed in nature? Read my Internet article: HOW FORENSIC SCIENCE REFUTES ATHEISM.
WHAT IS SCIENCE? Science simply is knowledge based on observation. No one observed the universe coming by chance or by design, by creation or by evolution. These are positions of faith. The issue is which faith the scientific evidence best supports.
Some things don’t need experiment or scientific proof. In law there is a dictum called prima facie evidence. It means “evidence that speaks for itself.”
An example of a true prima facie would be if you discovered an elaborate sand castle on the beach. You don’t have to experiment to know that it came by design and not by the chance forces of wind and water.
If you discovered a romantic letter or message written in the sand, you don’t have to experiment to know that it was by design and not because a stick randomly carried by wind put it there. You naturally assume that an intelligent and rational being was responsible.
I encourage all to read my popular Internet articles: NATURAL LIMITS TO EVOLUTION and HOW FORENSIC SCIENCE REFUTES ATHEISM
Visit my newest Internet site: THE SCIENCE SUPPORTING CREATION
Babu G. Ranganathan*
(B.A. Bible/Biology)
Author of popular Internet article, TRADITIONAL DOCTRINE OF HELL EVOLVED FROM GREEK ROOTS
*I have given successful lectures (with question and answer period afterwards) defending creation before evolutionist science faculty and students at various colleges and universities. I’ve been privileged to be recognized in the 24th edition of Marquis “Who’s Who in The East” for my writings on religion and science.
Wake me up when you’ve finished the lecture. Time and place. This is neither.
There’s a spacecraft leaving tomorrow for it be on it the lot of you
have your say