Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
IRISH WATER HAS pleaded guilty to breaking environmental laws following the discovery of sewage pollution at treatment plants in Dublin, Limerick, Galway and Cork.
The company, which is being prosecuted by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), pleaded guilty at Dublin District Court on to 11 charges under Waste Water Discharge (Authorisation) regulations. Irish Water had been prosecuted twice previously by the EPA and the court could hand down fines of up to €5,000 per offence, Judge John Brennan noted.
He adjourned the case for two weeks to consider what sanction he will impose.
Prosecuting solicitor Maeve Larkin said the EPA was proceeding with three charges in connection with a waste water treatment plant in Athenry, Galway. This facility takes in waste water for treatment and then discharges clean water into the Clarinbridge river.
It failed to complete required upgrades by the end of 2015 and had released water with excessive pollutants into the river and failed to report an incident. EPA inspector Una O’Callaghan said Irish Water had indicated to Irish Water that the required work to reduce ammonia and phosphorus in water had to be done by the third quarter of 2015.
Irish Water told the EPA it would comply by April 2016, then moved the date back to the second half of 2017 and Irish Water now says the upgrading work will not start until 2018 and is not expected to be completed until the following year.
Tests of the discharge showed excessive emissions of ammonia, which can kill fish, as well as phosphorus, which can be a risk to the aquatic environment, the court was told.
The EPA inspector agreed with Larkin that from July 20, 2105 until August 2016 there were 11 occasions when pollutant levels breached regulation limits. Judge John Brennan heard that ammonia levels varied between 10 and 73 times the limit. During the same period phosphorus levels were between four and 23 times the limit.
Irish Water failed to notify the EPA about a mechanical failure led to a breakdown at the plant on 4 May last year when 40% of the waste water taken in could not be treated.
The EPA inspector agreed with defence counsel Eoghan Cole that there was no risk to public health, fish kill at this site or need to carry out an acute clean-up. Due to lack of procedures in place staff did not notify the EPA, he said, adding that a training programme has been rolled out for them.
€5 million upgrade
Cole asked the court to note that Irish Water intend carry to out a €5m upgrade at the Athenry plant.
The next case involving four charges related to sewage overflowing at three waste water pump stations in Balbriggan, in north Co. Dublin last year. These led to a minor fish kill in a local river last May and Skerries beach being closed for the June bank holiday weekend last year.
The EPA learned about the beach closure from media reports and it had not been reported to them by Irish Water as required, said EPA inspector Brendan Kissane.
“Do not swim notices had to be put up”, he told the court.
On May 17 last, the Dublin Road pump station also overflowed onto the road and into the Bracken river resulting in five dead fish. Irish Water had taken over two of the pump stations from local authorities in 2014 but the third only became operational in 2015 when they were in control.
The EPA official agreed with Cole that Irish Water was co-operative.
Judge Brennan was told the next case related to two offences at a waste water treatment plant in Botherbue, in Cork. EPA inspector Patrick Chang said upgrade work was required by EPA to be completed by the end of 2014 but it is not going to happen until 2019. Discharges to the Brogeen River, which leads to a tributary of the Blackwater, contained pollutants which were a toxic to fish and could affect salmon reproduction. However, he agreed with defence counsel that there was not danger to public health and significant upgrades are planned.
Larkin said the last case related to two offences at Dromcolliher, Co. Limerick, at a 1940s built water treatment plant. The charges were for not commencing the first phase of urgently needed upgrade work by a Dec. 31, 2015 deadline and discharging water with excessive pollutants, said EPA inspector John Feehan. The first phase of the upgrades will not be completed until 2018, the court heard.
It is now trying to deal with seven times the amount of water it was designed to handle, the court heard.
Prior to Irish Water taking control of the facility in 2014 the Department of Environment had set aside the funds for the work.
Judge Brennan also noted that Irish Water was co-operative with the EPA and will pay prosecutions costs. The guilty plea meant a trial as long as a tribunal had been avoided, he remarked.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
He’s right we are witnessing the end of an era. He ran a great site but the craic is gone, all the best An fear Rua.
Too many keyboard warriors out there now.
Was a great forum but was ruined by a small number of trolls and the usual shite stirrers in recent years! Saying that it with will be sadly missed. Many of the posters had a great insight in Gaelic games.
Not-so-subtle lesson for The Journal here perhaps with regard to trolls.
It’s definitely become a major headache for forums – there are, after all, many examples of forums that should remain anonymous.
Maybe though, it’s time to reexamine the whole concept of defamation in Irish law, because right now it’s as broken as copyright law is after Sean Sherlock’s SI. If you have money, or can bluster and threaten without any scruples, then the law is perfectly suited to you; if you’re conservative about conflicts, or don’t have the money to have a legal team, then the law basicly lets others use the SLAPP approach to veto what you can and cannot say – whether or not you own the site.
I kinda see the difference between when a site starts up and a year or so after when the anonymous names start turning up and antagonising the forum. Early adopters are by and large decent people, but once a site gets popular, all multitude of people turn up either to push their worldview, have a rant, or deliberately try to “get a rise” out regular & new posters.
You see it on every comment section on every forum on the web. the prevalence of it is only controlled by the moderators & website proprietors
sorry to see this site go. Thanks An Fear Rua for all the news and insight over the past 12 years
I can understand what he means about earning revenue from the site, saying he never made more than €10,000 a year. I run a few sites one which is global, with american traffic I get an average ad click every 9 page views, for my Irish traffic I get an ad click about every 100 page views.
Do you not realise that if you click on an ad your identity and bank details are automatically stolen?!
cheers Brian, thanks for helping us publishers in the recession :-) not!
That was meant to be a joke making your point paddy!
The wider problem of the demise of online anonymity is exacerbated not so much by the presence of open identity forums but the rampant rise in usage of the internet.
When you go from 16 million users, to whom using some sort of handle was almost required, to 2 billion users in about 15 years then the understanding of self policing and responsibility vanishes.
If users can’t be responsible and self policing then they have to be made to be responsible and be policed and policing costs money. Small online fora can survive this without much expenditure, larger ones can’t unless people grow up.
On a wider scale this means that rather than bringing people together the Internet stratifies people, blowing some of the earlier ideals of the Web right out of the water.
A major pity that AFR is gone. Goes to show, the trolls always win. What began with informed, diverse discussion, was recently ending in acrimonious and often nonsensical arguments, much of it legally dubious. Good luck to Liam in his future ventures. Goes to show, the web is a dangerous platform, especially when people can post the most bizarre stuff anonymously. Some of the stuff in relation to the Limerick hurling scene was really out of order.
Doubt it has anything to do with anonymity. If this site was making say $10m a year instead of approx 10k I doubt it would have been closed. The real issue is creating web sites that only appeal to a very small niche audience (with apologies to GAA fans, it’s not a worldwide mass audience)
Bit of a whinger. The problem is the legal culture here. We need a free speech bit in constitution.
it’s his site. Free speech means you can set up a site of your own.
No such thiing as free peech on another person’s web forum.
Ever.
You enjoy your freedoms as the website owner allows you to.
Remember that. We are all guests.
But why should free speech extend to making outlandish allegations against people who aren’t going to be able to defend themselves, or shouldn’t have to? I’m not saying that’s what happened on the site, but it’s what does happen. ‘Innocent until proven guilty’ might apply in the courts, but it doesn’t apply in people’s minds — and a smear campaign, with little or no accountability, can do untold damage.
Free speech is precious and needs to be protected, but so too do innocent people.
Informed discussions ending in non sensical argumentative debates , I’m pretty sure I see that happening somewhere else lately , now where was it again…..
I think people should have to register with real name , photo and identity for online activity and when they are giving opinions , no matter how off the wall , they at least shouldnt be anonymous but I know that’s just personal opinion and not gonna happen any time soon.
I agree completely with his reasoning. Small online publishers are directly in competition with anybody who sets up a group on Facebook or other social media site on the same interest. They can tap into a huge membership whereas we have to struggle for every eyeball. Advertising / sponsorship for niche sites in practically impossible to find. I’ve been running Archiseek.com since 1996 and I reckon I’ve probably been approached half a dozen times in those years by a potential advertisers, and I’m proactive in trying to find them. In the same period, I’ve had lots of contact from lawyers about comments on the forums. It’s the main reason we turned off P45.net – it was costing money.
If I didn’t love it, I would have pulled the plug a decade ago.
As a regular reader and extremely rare poster I’m sorry to see this go. However, so many threads descended rapidly into name-calling. Any upcoming Limerick or Clare hurlers in particular should be glad to see it go – the amount of abuse directed at young amateur sportsmen was unreal at times. Real pity as there was some decent debate there too if you could find it. Some enjoyable random non-GAA stuff too – such as this thread about Limousin cattle
We were part of a very large site in the south east that was as big and had to shut down about 3 years ago for the same reason (Liam was a member).
To be honest, groups on Facebook kind of took over. Not worth the legal risk
Have to say the comments on Journal are a total dose lately. Almost like youtube. Seems a lot more relxed in the score section but still
It’s a pity the site has closed, I hope that an archive of the posts exists somewhere, there was a lot of funny stuff there. The trolls had begun to dominate on AFR of late, but the site itself was somewhat responsible for this, moderation wasn’t always consistent, lots of multiple aliases on the site, where trolls were banned they could re-register and post again in minutes.
Odd decision to just close it. With over 10,000 members he could have sold the site, it would be worth 5 to 10 grand at least.
Upgrade the site, improve the design and you could have a nice little earner for someone.
Good marketing Opportunity for Paddypower now. They should step in and save it :)
have your say