Advertisement

We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

©Rory Geary

All 174 Dáil seats filled as final two TDs elected in Cavan-Monaghan

All the latest political updates.

WE HAVE A full house. 

After three days of counting, the final make-up of the 34th Dáil is now clear after the final two seats were filled in the Cavan-Monaghan constituency. 

Fianna Fáil is now the largest party with 48 TDs, followed by Sinn Féin with 39 seats and Fine Gael with 38 seats.

Labour and the Social Democrats both took 11 seats; People Before Profit-Solidarity took three; Aontu took two; and the Green Party retained only one of its 12 seats. Independents and others took 21 seats.

Earlier, Labour’s Eoghan Kenny came out on top over Mick Barry after the outgoing People Before Profit TD withdrew his recount request. 

- Updates from Jane Moore and Daragh Brophy (now), Diarmuid Pepper and Lauren Boland (earlier)

With all the results in, a number of newly-elected TDs are appearing on RTÉ’s Upfront with Katie Hannon this evening. 

One of them is new Dublin Central TD, Labour’s Marie Sherlock, who took the last seat in the constituency ahead of Gerry ‘The Monk’ Hutch on Sunday.

“I wasn’t surprised at the vote I got, but nor was I entirely shocked at the vote that Gerard Hutch got either because there’s enormous frustration in our city and our country at the moment,” Sherlock says. 

Asked what Hutch said to her in the count centre, she says: “I think the first thing to say is that he got 3,000 votes and that has to be respected. I very clearly made a decision that I would shake the hand of anybody who commanded that vote in the Dublin Central constituency.”

She says Hutch wished her well and made it clear “that he felt he got a vote because of people’s frustration”.

“I made very clear that I will be a TD for every single person in Dublin Central and that I am frustrated about our constituency, the failures over many years. People feel left behind, and ultimately, I will work for everybody across the constituency.”

Sherlock said her gaining a seat is the result of “the product of four years hard slog on the streets, on our roads in Dublin Central. It wasn’t just about hard work, it was also about setting out a vision about how we could better our communities and better our city.”

In case you missed it, this was the moment that the final two TDs – Fianna Fáil’s Brendan Smith and Niamh Smyth – were elected in the Cavan-Monaghan constituency. 

So who were the winners and losers of the election?

fianna-fail-leader-micheal-martin-celebrates-after-he-was-deemed-elected-in-the-cork-south-central-constituency-at-the-election-count-centre-at-nemo-rangers-gaa-club-in-cork-after-voters-went-to-the Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo

Well, as they are now the biggest party in the Dáil, it’s clear that Micheál Martin and Fianna Fáil are the victors, with the Cork South-Central TD now looking likely to become Taoiseach for a second time. 

The biggest losers are undoubtedly the Green Party, who lost all but one of their seats. 

Our political reporter Jane Matthews has more here.

Here’s what the full house looks like. 

Screenshot (713) thejournal thejournal

You can see exactly who was elected in every constituency across the country with our General Election results centre

And that’s all 174 of them!

The final two seats up for grabs in the Dáil have been filled. 

Fianna Fáil’s Niamh Smyth and Brendan Smith have been elected in the Cavan-Monaghan constituency.

Following the distribution of Cathy Bennett’s surplus, Niamh Smyth finished on 11,058 votes while Brendan Smith had 10,886 votes. Aontú’s Sarah O’Reilly missed out on a seat, with 10,067 votes. 

Former Labour leader Alan Kelly retained his seat today, and sounds pretty keen on the prospect of entering government again. 

Kelly served as both a junior and senior minister in the Fine Gael-Labour government of 2011 to 2016. 

Perhaps power still suits him?

And some more pics from the Cavan-Monaghan count. 

Cavan Count 2 LT Outgoing TD Pauline Tully, who is now out of the running to keep her seat, alongside retired SF TD Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin - who became the first Sinn Féin representative to be elected to the Dáil in 1997. Lorraine Teevan Lorraine Teevan

_DSC5038 Fine Gael's Heather Humphreys, who announced in October that she would not be running again, congratulates the party's David Maxwell. ©Rory Geary ©Rory Geary

_DSC5321 Matt Carthy reclaimed his seat earlier today on the 12th count. ©Rory Geary ©Rory Geary

This just in from photographer Rory Geary in the Cavan-Monaghan count centre – the moment Cathy Bennett of Sinn Féin took her seat on the 13th count earlier this evening. 

Bennett joins her party colleague Matt Carthy in the Dáil.

Outgoing TD for SF Pauline Tully is out of the running. 

_DSC5555 ©Rory Geary ©Rory Geary

Our Political Editor Christina Finn has some analysis on why the ministers for health and disabilities lost their respective seats in this election. 

Stephen Donnelly has become one of the biggest casualties in the country’s election after he was eliminated in Wicklow in the early hours of this morning, while Anne Rabbitte lost her seat in Galway East yesterday.

According to Christina, it comes down to what a politician needs to remember when they are in high office.

The potholes matter, the local sports clubs matter, the traffic in and out of the county matters. Like it or loathe it but parish pump politics are embedded in the Irish political system.

But when Donnelly was in high office, he closed two constituency offices in the county, rarely held clinics with the public and is understood to have neglected the local Fianna Fáil cummann in the area.

His absence on the ground would be openly discussed by those within Fianna Fáil, as well as other local representatives.

This all came to the fore when the tallies were being counted in the Wicklow count centre on Saturday afternoon. Broken down into local areas, the votes gave the clearest indication that Donnelly was not going to get over the line. Why?

You can read her full analysis piece here.

It could be a long night in Drumalee. 

One of the three remaining seats in Cavan-Monaghan has been filled.

Sinn Féin’s Cathy Bennett has taken a second seat for the party in the five-seater constituency on the 13th count.

There are two seats left to fill and three candidates remaining: Fianna Fáil’s Brendan Smith and Niamh Smyth, and Aontú’s Sarah O’Reilly.

NorthernSound News / X (Formerly Twitter)

As we reported earlier, Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald has been in contact with the leaders of Social Democrats and Labour

Speaking this afternoon, Labour’s Ged Nash said this afternoon he was somewhat taken aback by the “hard neck” of McDonald contacting his party leader, stating that the party didn’t see fit to ask Sinn Féin voters to transfer left before the election.

He said it is “some stretch” to describe Sinn Féin as a left party.

Despite speaking to other party leaders, the path to power for Sinn Féin seems to have come to a dead end.

Sinn Féin, as is stands (with Cavan-Monaghan still to declare), will have at least 38 seats in the new Dáil, one more than it won in 2020. However, there has been an increase in the number of seats since the 33rd Dáil.

And as we await the final three seats in Cavan-Monaghan, a recap of how things look so far.

Fianna Fáil are out in front on 46 seats, while Sinn Féin and Fine Gael are tied on 38.

But with Sinn Féin councillor Cathy Bennett in a good chance in Cavan-Monaghan, Sinn Féin will be hoping to edge out Fine Gael. 

There are three seats to fill in Cavan-Monaghan and four candidates remaining. 

Sinn Féin’s Matt Carthy and Fine Gael’s David Maxwell have been elected.

That leave Sinn Féin councillor Cathy Bennett, and outgoing Fianna Fáil TDs Brendan Smith and Niamh Smyth, as well as Aontú’s Sarah O’Reilly. 

O’Reilly is around a thousand votes off Bennett, while Bennett is a few hundred votes behind Niamh Smyth and Brendan Smith.

The end is near on the 2024 general election (though of course the hard work of forming a government will start in earnest soon).

Outgoing Fianna Fáil TDs Brendan Smith and Niamh Smyth are at the count centre for the Cavan-Monaghan constituency, the only place still counting.

A final count should come in the next two or three hours. 

It was dramatic in Cork North-Central and here’s Niall O’Connor’s report following the conclusion of the count, as Ireland’s youngest TD Eoghan Kenny is elected after Mick Barry concedes.

And then there were three, with Cavan-Monaghan the only constituency to still be counting. 

In the past few minutes, Sinn Féin’s Matt Carthy made it over the line and now counting continues to fill the remaining three seats in the constituency. 

Labour’s Eoghan Kenny has been speaking to Niall O’Connor and he said he is “honoured” to have been elected in Cork North-Central.

He added that it’s a “real privilege” to be elected as the youngest member of the next Dáil.

And Mick Barry has been speaking to our reporter Niall O’Connor following the conclusion of the Cork North-Central recount. 

Rather than gaining ground on Eoghan Kenny, Barry was marginally losing ground with 63% of the votes counted.

“We’re not going to stay here ’til midnight just for the sake of it,” said Barry. 

“It’s clear the direction in which things were going and on that basis we called for the recount to end.”

And amid the excitement in Cork North-Central, everything has been officially ironed out in Tipperary North, where a full recount was also called.

abour’s Alan Kelly and Fianna Fáil’s Ryan O’Meara have been elected, meaning all three seats are now filled in Tipperary North.

And it’s all over in Cork North-Central, where Mick Barry has conceded, making Labour’s Eoghan kenny the youngest TD in the next Dáil

at the age of 24.

And while there’s still some TDs to elect, it’s been revealed in the past few minutes that Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald has been in contact with leaders of Social Democrats and Labour.

Sinn Féin’s Eoin Ó Broin meanwhile said the “outcome of the election is now clear”.

“The numbers are there for Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael to form a government together,” he said.

“This would be the worst possible outcome for the people of the country.” 

Ó Broin said McDonald has made contact with the leaders of the Social Democrats and Labour Party and “will be contacting the other progressive TDs and groupings this week”. 

“Our new increased parliamentary team will meet on Wednesday in Leinster House with Mary Lou McDonald and we will assess where we take things at that stage,” added Ó Broin.

And over in Louth, we’ve got a complete count.

Paula Butterly of Fine Gael, Erin McGreehan of Fianna Fáil and Ger Nash of Labour have all been elected – Nash is an incumbent TD. 

And it’s looking like Eoghan Kenny will become the youngest TD in the next Dáil, if this update by Niall O’Connor is anything to go by.

He reports that as of 4.30pm, 63% of votes have been recounted and the gap has now widened to 39, as the discrepancies found in the papers are benefitting Kenny rather than Mick Barry.

IMG_2009 Mick Barry pictured at today's recount. Niall O'Connor / The Journal Niall O'Connor / The Journal / The Journal

And another update from Niall O’Connor in Cork. 

He says things are moving quicker than might have otherwise been expected.

A discussion is now ongoing to decide what happens next.

It’s understood that there has been nothing substantial found so far that could change the result, with over 40,000 votes checked.

That would mean Labour’s Eoghan Kenny will become the youngest TD in the next Dáil.

Niall O’Connor has been camped out in Nemo Rangers since Saturday and he caught up with Labour’s Eoghan Kenny as the recount continues.

He said there was a “full entitlement” for Mick Barry to request a recount after only 35 votes were in the difference. 

At only 24, he will be the yougest person in the Dáil should he be elected.

There are four constituencies where work is ongoing to decide who will be making up the next Dáil.

It’s a long slog in Cavan-Monaghan, where only one TD has been returned – Fine Gael’s David Maxwell, who is taking up the seat left by Heather Humphreys. 

Work is also ongoing in Cork North-Central to separate Mick Barry from Eoghan Kenny, after Kenny came out on top by a mere 35 votes last night. 

Counting is also continuing in Co Louth, where two Sinn Féin TDs have been elected but there are still three seats left to fill. 

And in Tipperary North, Labour’s Alan Kelly and Fianna Fáil’s Ryan O’Meara are certain to be elected later, though there are some formalities to go through yet.

That’s it from me, Lauren. Handing you over now to my colleague Diarmuid Pepper – let’s see how many more seats can be filled today.

Niall expects we won’t see much news from the Cork North Central recount until around 6pm.

 

We have our first elections of the day (in daylight hours, that is).

Sinn Féin’s Réada Cronin, Fine Gael’s Joe Neville and Fianna Fáil’s Naoise Ó Cearúil have been elected on the twelfth and final count in Kildare North.

That means Fine Gael’s Bernard Durkan, a veteran TD since 1981, has lost his seat.

No luck for independent candidate Kevin Callan in his hope for a different result after calling that re-check in Louth.

The check found no discrepancies and Callan remains eliminated, allowing the next count to proceed.

Cavan-Monaghan has announced the results of its eleventh count and it’s bad news for outgoing Sinn Féin TD Pauline Tully, who only received six transfers from the surplus of elected Fine Gael candidate David Maxwell and has now been knocked out.

Transfers from Tully’s 7,868 votes will now be distributed. Her two Sinn Féin colleagues Matt Carthy and Cathy Bennett, currently on 10,981 and 8,220 votes should do well from those.

Carlow Kilkenny 11

The Journal understands that members of the Fianna Fáil parliamentary party are due to meet in Leinster House on Wednesday at Leinster House to discuss the outcome of the election.

Fianna Fáil is expected to emerge from the election with the largest share of seats, giving it a big advantage going into government formation talks.

Fianna Fáil’s deputy leader Jack Chambers, who was re-elected in Dublin West, has said he does not expect a coalition to be formed before Christmas.

“I don’t expect a government to be formed in mid-December. When the Dail is due to meet on the 18th of December, probably a Ceann Comhairle (speaker) can be elected, and there’ll have to be time and space taken to make sure we can form a coherent, stable government,” Chambers told RTÉ.

“I don’t think it should take five months like it did the last time – Covid obviously complicated that – but I think all political parties need to take the time to see what’s possible and try and form a stable government for the Irish people.”

2.77666136 Jack Chambers PA PA

More rechecking happening, this time in Louth. 

Independent candidate Kevin Callan was deemed eliminated on the nineteenth count but he was only four votes below the candidate above him, Alison Comyn of Fianna Fáil, and so has requested those votes be checked again.

This is what happens in election end games – every vote really does count.

In a sample of 25% of ballot papers, there were 29 discrepancies found, according to People Before Profit-Solidarity’s Mick Barry.

A full recount is getting underway, which could take several days unless the candidate withdraws the request early.

However, it’s a different story in Cork North Central.

After a recount this morning of the latest count, a full recount has been requested, our News Correspondent Niall O’Connor tells us.

The recount put Jim Ryan three votes ahead of Michael Smith in Tipperary North. Michael Smith has now conceded and subsequent counts can proceed.

In Tipperary North, the recount has actually now been withdrawn, RTÉ is reporting.

Recounting is also ongoing in Tipperary North.

After its ninth count, the two lowest candidates – Fianna Fáil’s Michael Smith and independent Jim Ryan – where apart by only seven votes, with the edge going to Smith.

There’s been two rechecks done, which put Smith one and two votes ahead respectively, after which Ryan requested a recount.

Lunchtime at the Nemo Rangers GAA club. Niall reckons the number of errors found has been small.

 

Louth is one of the few constituencies still counting.

It has just finished its nineteenth count and eliminated independent Kevin Callan, who leaves behind 5,682 votes.

Any transfers will now be redistributed between the remaining candidates: Labour’s Ged Nash, Fine Gael’s Paula Butterly, Fianna Fáil’s Erin McGreehan and Fianna Fáil’s Alison Comyn.

Nash is only a measly 50 votes away from the quota so will likely be elected on the next count or the one after to take the constituency’s third seat. He’d be joining Sinn Féin’s Ruarí Ó Murchú and Joanna Byrne, both already elected here. 

Louth 19 1

Louth 19 2

Let’s check in on how the recount is going in Cork North Central.

Here’s what Niall O’Connor has written about it from the ground:

In the early hours of this morning as Eoghan Kenny of Labour was declared as taking the last seat by just 35 votes Barry, of People Before Profit Solidarity (PBPS), requested the move.

Martin Harvey, the returning officer for Cork City, met with both Labour and PBPS representatives. It was decided after that meeting that the recount would begin with an examination of bundles of 50 votes at a time.

Tally keepers have said that it is understood that 15 individual errors have been identified in the bundles.

Harvey has told The Journal this morning that if there is a discrepancy in those bundles then a full recount will get underway – we are likely to get a result from that initial examination around lunchtime.

counting-continues-for-irelands-general-election-at-nemo-rangers-gaa-club-after-cork-north-central-candidate-mick-barry-for-solidarity-requested-a-recount-picture-date-monday-december-2-2024 Counters begin work in Cork North Central this morning. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo

Thanks for the liveblogging Muiris. No thanks for the on-the-spot lunch question, which was a rather unsophisticated assortment of snacks.

I’m heading off to work in the background of Journal towers.

I’ll let Lauren Boland fill you in on the rest, including on what she had for her lunch.

Independent Councillor Barry Heneghan, elected late last night on the 16th count in Dublin Bay North, will be one of the youngest members of the new Dáil at 26 years of age.

He’s a protégé of Finian McGrath, former Independent TD for the same constituency and junior minister for disability in the 2016-2020 government of Fine Gael and the Independent Alliance.

The Journal spoke to McGrath yesterday evening, before Heneghan’s election to the fourth of five seats in this closely contested constituency, about the advice he’d give any potential junior coalition partner about entering government formation talks.

McGrath said it’s important to have six or seven clear priorities ready before getting round the table with the big parties – and added that he and Heneghan “have our six items already in our head”.

“No talks about talks,” McGrath said.

His prediction? The next government will comprise Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael and a handful of Independents, rather than Labour or the Social Democrats.

That’s what former Progressive Democrats leader Michael McDowell and former Labour leader Pat Rabbitte told us too.

You can read the full article here:

Women for Elections have said the gender balance in the Dáil is heading in the right direction, but slowly.

CEO of the advocacy organisation, Brian Sheehan, said it was a “historic” election for women, with female candidates representing 32% of first-preference votes – the equivalent of 70 quotes. 

A total of 39 women candidate were elected, as of this morning, and the group expects 44 female TDs to be elected to the Dáil – representing a quarter of all politicians in the Irish parliament.

“We are going in the right direction, but far too slowly,” Sheehan said.

“With a record number of women running, we could have expected to see more women to be elected. If we are serious about achieving equal representation for women in political life, further work is necessary,” he added.

Emma Hickey has detailed the election of the 100% Redress candidate Charles Ward in Donegal yesterday.

Ward ran for the party in the local elections earlier this year and failed to be elected, but now he’s headed for Dáil Eireann, where he plans to represent homes in the area that have been affected by defective building blocks. 

Speaking to Ocean FM prior to his election yesterday, Ward said that the government would be forced to listen to his party’s demands for 100% redress.

“They’ve got one choice now. They have to listen to us, because I’m going to be on the floor of the Dáil.”

You can read Emma’s full write up here:

Fianna Fáil Dublin West TD Jack Chambers has told Newstalk Breakfast  this morning that his party will be waiting to discuss government formation until after all the votes have been counted.

He said Fianna Fáil are hopeful that it will return 48 seats to the Dáil, as is projected, and will then internally debate the next move.

Meanwhile, parties on the left are calling for their colleagues to stall talks with the major political groups in order to gain power over those seeking for form a coalition (or, maybe, bragging rights).

Sinn Féin are making the point that, with so many left and centre-left TDs elected on a “mandate of change”, it is necessary for smaller parties of shared values, and who may be seen as a potential coalition partner to make their case on behalf of those groups.

As is the topic of the day – recounts.

And no better man to tell us about the latest re-tallying of votes than Cork Returning Officer Martin Harvey.

He managed the longest-ever recount in Irish history when Sinn Féin’s Liadh Ní Riada was up against the Green Party’s Grace O’Sullivan during the 2019 Euro elections. 

Harvey is now overseeing the recount in Cork North Central, where People Before Profit’s Mick Barry requested a recount to double check the votes between himself and Labour’s Eoghan Kenny.

Harvey spoke with our news correspondent Niall O’Connor outside Nemo Rangers in Cork, telling us about the latest deal that was reached between staff and the candidates.

Good afternoon.

Muiris Ó Cearbhaill here after escaping from the RDS last night. Who knew more than 10 hours under fluorescent lighting would have no impact on your state of mind?

As was said, I’m covering for Lauren for the hour as she heads to get a break.

As the dust is settling on the campaign – though some madness is still ongoing – ‘coalitionogy’ is in full swing.

You’ll hear a lot of chatter around this party going into government with that party and other parties calling for that party to stay out of government with this party.

Votes are still left to be counted however.

While some discussions might take place today, it will be a little while longer before we get the full, real picture as to how this election played out.

Stick with us anyways as we bring you everything and anything you need to know.

I’m jumping out for a quick lunch and leaving you in the hands of my colleague Muiris Ó Cearbhaill (who managed to make it from the RDS yesterday after reporting on the results there, unlike our Niall still down at counting in Cork).

Labour’s candidate Eoghan Kenny, who was considered to have won the seat last night but is now subject to the recount, is also waiting for the result, though he’s not at the centre yet.

Labour Councillor Peter Horgan spoke to Niall at the centre about the recount process.

 

People Before Profit-Solidarity TD Mick Barry is awaiting the results of the recount. 

On government formation talks, Kerry Independent TD Michael Healy-Rae has said this morning that his “phone is always on”.

Not too many count centres still active today but our News Correspondent Niall O’Connor has arrived at the at the Nemo Rangers GAA club, where a recount called last night has now commenced.

Writing an opinion piece in The Journal this morning, Dr Brendan Flynn of University of Galway says that overall, this election has given us “more of the same”.

“It arguably was an election where reality took a sneaky pre-Christmas holiday. Manifestos tripped over each to promise lavish spending plans combined with a medley of tax cuts in various fetching ideological hues,” Dry Flynn writes.

“The strong whiff of ‘promising cake, and eating it as well’ sat oddly with the rest of the planet careering towards climate melt-down, casual threats of nuclear war on Europe’s periphery, or an impending dismantling of the free trade system, so vital to our economic success over the last decades.”

Of the seats filled at this stage, Fianna Fáil is leading with 43 TDs. Sinn Féin and Fine Gael follow with 36 each.

15 independent candidates have been elected so far.

The Social Democrats have enjoyed a boost to numbers this election, with 11 TDs over the line.

The Labour Party has won eight seats so far while Independent Ireland has won four.

People Before Profit/Solidarity will have at least three TDs in the next Dáil and Aontú will have at least two.

It’s been a challenging election for the Greens, with only one seat won, which was by party leader Roderic O’Gorman.

The 100% Redress party and Workers and Unemployed Action party have each won one seat.

If you were following along with the results over the weekend and you’re looking to catch up on what you missed while you were asleep, we have you covered. Here are all the late-night elections that have happened since around midnight in the early hours of this morning:

The majority of the seats in the 34th Dáil have now been filled across the first two days of counting.

Here’s a full list of all the TDs elected so far on Saturday and Sunday:

And here’s our Results Centre, where you can explore exactly how the votes were distributed in each count in every constituency:

Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.

Close
61 Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Submit a report
    Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
    Thank you for the feedback
    Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

    Leave a commentcancel

     
    JournalTv
    News in 60 seconds