Skip to content
Support Us

We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

Gary Simpson was not awarded damages by the judge. Sam Boal/RollingNews.ie

No damages for prisoner whose rights were breached by being forced to defecate in chamber pot

The High Court ruled that Gary Simpson’s right to privacy was breached.

Updated 2.02 pm

THE STATE BREACHED the constitutional rights to privacy of a prisoner who had to urinate and defecate in a chamber pot or other receptacle in front of a fellow or fellow prisoners and then slop out his shared cell, a High Court judge decided today.

Mr Justice Michael White said he was not awarding prisoner Gary Simpson damages because of his partly untruthful and sometimes highly exaggerated evidence about the alleged harmful effect the treatment meted out to him in Mountjoy Prison had on his health and wellbeing.

Judge White, in a reserved judgment, also refused Simpson a declaration that his constitutional rights not to be subjected to inhuman and degrading treatment had been breached.

The court heard that Simpson had to use and empty chamber pots because he had no in-cell lavatory facilities. He claimed he had been humiliated, degraded and had his human rights violated because of the practice forced on him.

He alleged he experienced feelings of worthlessness and that his mental health had been affected by having to endure the slopping out practices in Mountjoy.

Simpson claimed that in 2013 he had to tolerate the degrading conditions while sharing a single cell with another prisoner for a period of eight months in D1 wing of the prison.

The court was told he had been convicted of robbery and had been serving three years in the prison. He had been granted a voluntary personal protection transfer to D1 wing because he had felt vulnerable to attack from other inmates.

Judge White was told he was often subject to 23-hour lock-up and sometimes got out for less than an hour. He claimed he could have been locked up for longer than 23 hours before being let out.

Simpson alleged there was no in-cell sanitation and no running water and that prisoners would be provided with receptacles in which to urinate and defecate. They had to eat their meals in the same cell they had to urinate and defecate in. They were given a basin, soap and water with which to wash themselves.

Difficulty

He claimed he had difficulty defecating into the receptacles he had been provided with and would defecate into the pages of a newspaper which he would then use to wrap up his excreta and place in a plastic bag.

He had no proper in-cell facilities for washing his hands after urinating or defecating and this created a considerable risk of infection.

Prisoners would have to dispose of urine and faeces in the slopping area and Simpson claimed some prisoners would urinate in sinks in the slopping out area that were designated for washing.

Simpson’s counsel, Micheal O’Higgins SC and James Devlin SC, had told the court that the slopping out regime had been condemned in 1993 by the European Committee on the Prevention of Torture and had also been criticised in a number of reports including by the State Inspector of Prisons.

A Report by the Thornton Hall Review Group had addressed the impact of such conditions on prospects of rehabilitation and, in 1995, the State had accepted their concerns.

It had not been until 2010 that the State had started a programme of prison refurbishment to achieve single cell occupancy and in-cell sanitation.

Bodily integrity

Judge White refused Simpson a declaration that the conditions and circumstances of his detention in 2013 breached his rights to bodily integrity and to protection of his health as guaranteed under Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

He said there had been an imbalance in the ability of Simpson and the State to tender evidence and, in any action in which an individual alleged institutional abuse, the court had to be careful to ensure that the evidence provided on behalf of the institution was scrutinised carefully to the extent that the court was satisfied that the institutional witnesses had not closed ranks about the allegations made.

He said that in a cell of two occupants, and on exceptional occasions three, there was no toilet or running water.

Each prisoner was provided with a chamber pot which had a lid and the prisoner was required to take this pot to the toilet area and slop out by pouring the contents into a slop hopper on the landing.

“It should be stated from the outset that this practice was uncivilised and a poor reflection on the defendants that it still existed 28 years after the publication of the original Whittaker report into the penal system of July 1985 and 19 years after the first report of the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman and Degrading Treatment or Punishment,” Judge white said.

He said that subject to his criticism of the practice of having to defecate in one’s cell in the first place the court was satisfied the chamber pot was satisfactory and that the lid fritted snugly.

There would be an unpleasant smell initially when a prisoner defecated in a cell which was unsatisfactory from the point of the prisoner and his cellmate.

The court had been told that if the lid was replaced promptly onto the pot the smell would diffuse after a reasonably short period of time.

It was unacceptable that the prisoner had to try and defecate in a crouched position and to urinate while standing up which would have led to splashing and spillages. Modest screens could have been provided without difficulty.

Judge White said prisoner Simpson was a volatile prisoner who had a number of disciplinary offences and had been involved in two separate serious incidents with a prison officer against whom he had amplified a difficult personal relationship into an invented conspiracy.

The court did not accept Simpson’s evidence that the overall approach of prison staff in Mountjoy was one of contempt or unhelpfulness.

“The court has to be frank and I have to say there were huge issues with the credibility of Mr Simpson,” the judge said.

“He lied about having stomach cramps while waiting to get out of his cell to go to the toilet and the court is, frankly, of the view it could not award damages because of the gross exaggeration of his evidence on a number of matters and his untruthful evidence.”

Read: An average of 12 phones are seized in Irish prisons every week >

Read: Prison officers seized two weapons a day over the last five years >

Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.

Author
View 49 comments
Close
49 Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Get Lost Eircodes
    Favourite Get Lost Eircodes
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 2:21 PM

    Ireland… The best little country in the world to screw the self employed…

    143
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Homer's imp son
    Favourite Homer's imp son
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 2:27 PM

    The best country in the world to be a politician

    111
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Paul Mc
    Favourite Paul Mc
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 2:43 PM

    Having Noonan in charge of Finance is like having a fox in charge of a hen house. .

    76
    See 1 more reply ▾
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Bobby Phelan
    Favourite Bobby Phelan
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 5:07 PM

    If they do away with usc they will increase lpt dont be so naive the banks were guaranteed.

    14
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute john g mcgrath
    Favourite john g mcgrath
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 2:19 PM

    Having 1000 plus children in hotel rooms B and B ect and having an 85 year old woman pass away after 2 days on a trolley should be addressed first !!

    93
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute John Clark
    Favourite John Clark
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 2:29 PM

    Take the 13 Billion from Apple or whatever the government can get at this stage and put some prosperity back into Ireland.

    What a load of useless wasters the above people are. Half a billion for the total budget for Ireland.A fiver for the old age pensioners……

    Waffle waffle waffle.

    Don’t forget drag the Apple debacle out for another five years while the people of Ireland struggle because of Noonan.

    38
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Cathal O'Sullivan
    Favourite Cathal O'Sullivan
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 6:14 PM

    Are you really so naive to think that Apple will just hand over 13 billion to the Irish government and then continue happily employing the thousands of people nationwide?

    12
    See 1 more reply ▾
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Stephen Brady
    Favourite Stephen Brady
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 6:27 PM

    Cathal how long would it take for apples workforce to pay €13bn in tax? There are I think 6,000 of them.

    6
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Fred Johnson
    Favourite Fred Johnson
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 2:28 PM

    Let’s not be fooled here. It’s not a billion euro giveaway. It’s a 3 billion euro giveaway. That’s how much government spending is increasing over the past year. Why the difference? Because the other 2 billion is eaten up by government “commitments”, ie increases in public sector pay and more money into the black hole health budget, most likely eaten up by consultants fees. The 1 billion is what is left to “play with”.

    Imagine we had not increased public sector pay this year. We could pretty much half the USC in a single year. The government is using and abusing the middle class and private sector who create the wealth by retaining the USC to feed the insatiable public sector, welfare recipients and health consultants.

    68
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Eoin McDonnell
    Favourite Eoin McDonnell
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 2:44 PM

    Yea your right lets knock teachers, nurses and gardai pay down to minimum wage…that will surely attract the best and stop them emigrating to Dubai etc!!

    27
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Fred Johnson
    Favourite Fred Johnson
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 2:49 PM

    @Eoin McDonnell:

    Eoin if we had halved the USC instead of giving pay rises, the nurses, guards and teachers would have benefited too.

    34
    See 8 more replies ▾
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Donnacha Bhoicaire
    Favourite Donnacha Bhoicaire
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 2:56 PM

    @ Fred totally agree
    Not too mention the scroungers year after year on the dole

    36
    Karl
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Karl
    Favourite Karl
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 2:59 PM

    It’s not an increase in public sector pay.. Its a very partial restoration of pay and then only for certain grades !

    16
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Eoin McDonnell
    Favourite Eoin McDonnell
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 3:00 PM

    I don’t know anyone in the public sector who has had a pay rise, I know the younger more vulnerable members have had ONLY A FRACTION of their pay RESTORED but nope no pay rises I am afraid…

    13
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Fred Johnson
    Favourite Fred Johnson
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 3:03 PM

    @Eoin McDonnell:

    “Restore” to what? 2008 levels? Based on tax revenues from an unsustainable property bubble? Have a think about that.

    You have no moral right to 2008 levels of pay. We couldn’t afford it then and we can’t afford it now, they use the USC to pay for it.

    29
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Liam Mullane
    Favourite Liam Mullane
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 3:40 PM

    @Karl: Yes but a cut to USC benefits all workers across all sectors.

    11
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Stephen Brady
    Favourite Stephen Brady
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 6:29 PM

    Fred yes if the ps didn’t get a pay rise you could cut usc. How much inconvenience do you think the resulting strikes would cause you. Public sector workers are running out of patience as it is. They won’t take much more bs.

    5
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Stephen Brady
    Favourite Stephen Brady
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 6:33 PM

    Yes Fred but that would not be what we were promised. We agreed to a temporary pay cut to help us get out of a tight spot. We are out of that spot apparently so pay us. Keep the recovery going ;)

    5
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Albert Brennerman
    Favourite Albert Brennerman
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 7:07 PM

    @Fred Johnson: Thats short sgihted public private nonsense , it was some wealth created there in the 2010 when the Troika landed to convert private to sovereign debt. The public service shouldered it on the double pay cuts, usc and Fempi as well as no budgets to properly complete jobs. This was right and fair.
    Public workers now continue to pay USC , pay reductions and the emergency reductions in FEMPI, so roughly double your USC that’s what comes out of a nurse,garda,firefighter,civil servant pay cheque. You would swear a public servant lives in a different economy or eats a different type of bread and their kids automatically have storks delivering uniforms and football boots. So when Dublin Bus gets 12% Luas workes 18% , these people are completing with public servants among others in the housing market.
    Seriously consider inviting Apple/Google/Pfizer here and saying to them unfortunately we have no Gardai working today so the army is on the streets but its not as bad the hospitals were closed last week. No investment. The jobs these people do are real jobs and necessary job roles in a functioning society. We’re all in this little place together and truth is without foreign direct investment we’d still be a basket case economy and without stability you can’t have that.

    7
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Ben McArthur
    Favourite Ben McArthur
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 2:40 PM

    It’s not a giveaway. It was our money before the government forcibly took it from us. At most, it’s the Mafia boss sending us a wedding present after years of running a protection racket.

    40
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Get Lost Eircodes
    Favourite Get Lost Eircodes
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 3:22 PM

    @Ben McArthur: Who are the government….a foreign power???

    4
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Dick Woody
    Favourite Dick Woody
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 3:37 PM

    @Get Lost Eircodes: They are the proxy of foreign powers such as the IMF and the EU. They have no loyalty to the Irish people, that’s for sure.

    20
    See 1 more reply ▾
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Ben McArthur
    Favourite Ben McArthur
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 3:40 PM

    Racketeers who have acquired the veneer of legitimacy by pretending every so often that we have the chance to throw them out. If politics stopped tomorrow, the real government would continue. Look at Belgium, who supposedly had no government for over a year. Does anyone think it really made any difference?

    9
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Juan Franc
    Favourite Juan Franc
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 3:35 PM

    First priority will be the golden circle closely followed by the gombeens, cronies and sleeveens.The only difference the ordinary punter will notice is the increase in government advertising/self promotion in the poddle like media,

    27
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Dick Woody
    Favourite Dick Woody
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 3:33 PM

    Sew up your pockets, Jabba the Hutt wants to remove the contents and turn them inside out .

    23
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Patrick J. O'Rourke
    Favourite Patrick J. O'Rourke
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 4:49 PM

    “incentives will be rolled out to encourage entrepreneurship”. I fell off my chair reading that and I’m sure I’m not the only one. After the way small business has been treated for years anyone with sense will go elsewhere with their energy, brains and passion to start a business. Ireland exports its young qualified people and its potential indigenous businesses. When the multinationals all go to China or somewhere what will there be left here? Just fat politicians on massive pensions who will tell us it’s our own fault.

    20
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Neuville-Kepler62F
    Favourite Neuville-Kepler62F
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 8:30 PM

    29,000 sign on Change.org petition for Reform of the daft Irish Motor Tax system … €280 for new Merc … €580 for 10 yr old 1.6L … the most regressive unfair motor tax system in the EU. poor subsidising the rich … a disgusting society to live in.

    Pre-budget submission made to Dept of Finance on behalf of 29,000 signatories …. 87,000 visited the Change.org site.

    https://www.change.org/p/unfair-car-tax-law

    5
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Niall Donnelly
    Favourite Niall Donnelly
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 7:14 PM

    I’d have no problem with self employed receiving more tax credits but they cants prove their income. Can other employees claim expenses and vat back too?

    2
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute now-now-now
    Favourite now-now-now
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 2:56 PM

    Free the Journal 50

    1
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute LITTLEONE
    Favourite LITTLEONE
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 3:22 PM

    @now-now-now:
    Haha. Let the cat out.

    Powerabbey
    Sep 19th 2016, 10:15 AM # 33 1
    Free the Journal 50

    11
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Jimmy Riddler
    Favourite Jimmy Riddler
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 3:54 PM

    @LITTLEONE: You can see Dane’s hand writ large all over the comments section, every now and again he trips himself up. It must be hard for the most profilic profile maker to keep track of them all, especially in between driving lessons, I just hope the haste is not him texting whilst driving..:)

    8
    See 2 more replies ▾
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute LITTLEONE
    Favourite LITTLEONE
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 4:24 PM

    Free the 50 accounts

    9
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Alois Irlmaier
    Favourite Alois Irlmaier
    Report
    Oct 4th 2016, 2:14 AM

    @now-now-now: Are they that bad at buying a round?

    1
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Kerry Blake
    Favourite Kerry Blake
    Report
    Oct 3rd 2016, 6:52 PM

    Ah sure Ireland’s a wash with money no other country can afforded to turn down € 13 billion in un-payed taxes. There will be at least a fiver for everyone in the audience.

    1
Submit a report
Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
Thank you for the feedback
Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.

Leave a comment

 
cancel reply
JournalTv
News in 60 seconds