Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
THE ASSOCIATION OF Garda Sergeants and Inspectors (AGSI) will hold its annual conference this week – although Justice Minister Alan Shatter won’t be attending.
High on the agenda during the ‘Haddington Road: Your Association. Your Review’ conference will be the reform they would like to see take place in an Garda Síochána.
The AGSI’s 31 branches will debate 23 motions, including:
General Secretary John Redmond added they they have introduced a new feature to the conference this year in the form of a panel debate.
We pose the question – ‘what should a modern police force look like?’ We have external experts joining us so that the views are representative of modern Ireland and not just of our Association.
Panel members include Tom O’Malley, Senior Lecturer in Law, NUI Galway, Tony Geoghegan, CEO, Merchants Quay Ireland and broadcaster Marc Coleman.
John Redmond of AGSI will also sit on the panel, and Jonathan Healy of Newstalk will chair the debate.
As Minister Shatter will not be attending, acting Garda Commissioner Nóirín O’Sullivan will address delegates tomorrow afternoon, and will take their questions.
The conference will run until Wednesday 16 April at the Malton Hotel in Killarney.
I never really understood what the death penalty is trying to achieve. It seems to take the assumption that criminals won’t commit a serious crime for fear of the consequence of being put to death.
If criminals committing serious crimes had a fear of the consequences then half the prisons of the world would be empty
The same could be said for long prison terms. It depends on how you look at the prison system really. If you look at it as simply a way to deter other criminals then it is not effective on it’s own. If you look at it as a way to rid society of a particularly dangerous person then it is generally effective.
I think it better than the irish policy of killing someone and been released after 5/6 years, then strolling off to the airport and going on holidays…
you wouldn’t be saying that if you committed murder in ireland. I reckon the whole system has to be overhauled and reform detention centre’s for re-offenders. Kind of like emerald city in the tv show ‘OZ’ but more realistic. Education and learning what make’s each individual tick is the key here, not lock them up eave them out mentality.
Yeah as you say it applies to long term sentences as well, they don’t seem to work as a deterrent either. The whole justice system seems fundamentally flawed. No matter what the punishment its going to be reactive, without proactive measures to stop crime all that will happen is more and more prison overcrowding
Bring it to ireland
What? State sanctioned Barbarism? No thanks http://mobile.nytimes.com/2015/04/13/opinion/152-innocents-marked-for-death.html?referrer=
To test in pidgeons of course
I get the usual points raised by anti death penalty crowd. But in that case it would be good if life jail term actually meant life jail term – not 10 years.
Companies get sued for false advertising. Life jail in Europe is the biggest false advertising to me I heard.
Watch the brilliant documentary ‘Into the Abyss’ by master filmaker Warner Herzog.
It will really force you to re think those views you have in favour of the death penalty :)
Backward, uneducated, god loving savages…god and violence go hand in hand and a terrible example to children…”we kill people to show that killing people is wrong”…duh!…spa’s
An eye for an eye
And everyone is blind.
@Paul Lane – how do you make out that God and violence go hand in hand? Did you just make that up?
Not true, the last man will have one eye left. Serious crimes deserve serious punishment including the loss of ones right to life. We are too soft in this country and should have at least one method of execution available to our courts.
Have ye read the bible? God be like “Here sheep, kill your son if you love me”. Sheep be like “ok”. God be like “Ahhhhhhh, only joking, I will kill the majority of the human race one day”.. God is a violent wind up merchant :)
Two wrongs don’t make a right.
Being locked up behind bars with no human contact other than being fed is punishment enough .
Exclusive from our star witness Michael Clinton!
Can’t see a police officer facing the same treatment for killing an innocent person like in recent times..
In Texas if you kill someone you could get the death penalty in Ireland you could be freed in 5 years with a couple of million euros in the bank account all set for a new life in the sun.
Who has the better justice system?
Death penality is and can be proved wrong when evidence found can acquit someone of a crime. No point in saying oops we made a mistake after someone is injected to death
I suppose it’s slightly preferable to having the cops execute them before they even get charged.
Could use it in the southern parts. Cork could be the Texas of Ireland!
Ah Texas will you ever learn?
Good enough for them they won’t do it again
What about those who didn’t do it and are executed Brian?
Good, we should have the death penalty here!
Trolling would be a capital offence and you’d be first to be ceremoniously despatched
As long as innocent people can be executed, there is no justification for this. What about the lad in Alabama last week who was exonerated after 30 odd years on death row? Anyone who supports this is a savage, backward animal. If it’s such a deterrent why is the crime rate in the good ole US of A still so high? Ask yourselves that before you thump your bible you rotten rednecks.
Should be same here for those found guilty of capital murder, terrorism and child rape
Good these thugs brought pain n suffering by murdering ppl so I say fair play if they’re execution is painful
The most worrying thing about a barbaric law like the death penalty, is how many people in this country seem to think it’s actually a good idea.
Child rape, while probably the most horrible crime imaginable, still doesn’t warrant the death penalty. Firstly, most of these rapes are committed by relatives, so if the death penalty was in place the chances of it being reported would drop drastically. Secondly, it creates an added incentive to murder the child, insofar as the rapist will think their chances of not being caught would be better if the child wasn’t around to talk about it. The justice of the rusty knife would be far more applicable in these cases.
Just a quick question. …should someone who murders someone else and leaves family and love ones with that person forever, be allowed to live and have their loved ones be able to visit chat and engage in their lives?? I think not if you take someone’s else’s life you should not be allowed live yours regardless of how barbaric it may be after all that person didn’t cars how much he or she hurt the other person
have your say