Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
THE OMBUDSMAN FOR Children’s Office saw a 79% increase in complaints last year, with a large proportion relating to challenges faced by children and their families during the Covid-19 restrictions.
In 2021 there were 2,126 complaints made to the Ombudsman for Children’s Office, with 908 of these directly related to Covid-19 issues, according to the Ombudsman’s annual report.
These issues included restrictions in schools, uncertainty surrounding the Leaving Certificate, facemasks and supports for children with disabilities.
The largest number of complaints (787) came from Dublin, followed by Cork (340), Galway (319) and Limerick (319). Over half of the complaints in 2021 related to education, with 10% of those relating to bullying.
“Children are often recognised for their ability to learn, to adapt, to endure difficulties, to recover and to accept change,” Ombudsman for Children Dr Niall Muldoon said ahead of the publication of the report later this morning.
“But even the strongest of us have our limits and in 2021 even the most resilient child was tested.
In 2021 children, and indeed the public services providing for them, had to simply ‘get on with it’. Children were expected to make-do with the stop-start nature of school, they were expected to make friends behind masks, and they were expected to accept the cancelled plans, the curtailed experiences.
“The impact of the past two years can be clearly seen in the issues being raised with the OCO and I expect that there will be a knock-on effect for years to come.”
He said an investment in children’s futures and commitment from government is needed to ensure the State does not miss the opportunity to do things better.
Case studies
A number of case studies are highlighted in the report, including a 12-year-old girl who has dyslexia who faced a two-year delay in getting a laptop for her schoolwork. An application on her behalf when she was 10 years old was refused with no explanation or information on how to appeal the decision, the report notes.
The refusal had been communicated to her parents through a short, hand written note. The Ombudsman’s office said the girl’s diagnosis and the needs outlined in the application should have been enough for her to qualify for this assistive technology.
It was not until a second application was made, after she moved schools, that her laptop was approved. Her school principal told the Ombudsman that it had been more difficult for the child to reach her academic potential with no laptop, particularly during school closures.
The report also included details of complaints about housing issues that were impacting on children.
In the case of a brother and sister, named as James Junior and Rosie in the report, the family had been living in emergency accommodation since 2018. Rosie had been born into emergency accommodation and due to a health issue at birth doctors wrote to the local authority expressing concern about the suitability of accommodation provided.
“Unaddressed maintenance and repair issues at the emergency accommodation, including a hole in the ceiling which let rain in were other issues included in the complaint,” the report notes.
The Ombudsman’s office engaged with the local authority, escalating communications to the Director of Operations level after initial questions went unanswered. In November last year the local authority identified a three bedroom house for the family.
“When we last spoke to the family in January 2022 they were delighted with their home and how having their own place had improved their lives,” the report states.
James [the children's father] spoke of improvements to his overall mental health and Patricia [the children's mother] talked about less of a strain on the couple’s own relationship. Both went on to say that James Jnr and Rosie were ‘like different children’ and that they loved having their own room.
The report also highlighted a complaint from a foster carer, named as Anne, who expressed concern about three children aged between nine and 12 years old that she and her husband were caring for.
These concerns included:
She reported that she had to “fight” for therapeutic services on behalf of the children and the foster carer said she had paid herself for play therapy for one of the children after he had been refused services by the HSE.
In her complaint she stated that in the five years since the children were first received into care, no service had been identified to address the trauma the children had experienced.
The Ombudsman’s office engaged with Tusla and the social work team around the children. The report states that significant steps were taken to resolve issues and funding has been provided for one of the children to engage with a suitable trauma informed therapist.
Tusla has confirmed it will complete a short-term specific intervention with the other two children, but this will not be provided on a longterm basis. This short-term service has yet to commence, the report notes.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
That’s what one calls a jail sentence Take note judiciary in ireland
They won’t take note, why would they?
In Ireland the mandatory sentence for murder is “Life”. The judge has no power to give any other sentence. They are not allowed to put in minimum terms. The actual terms served for life sentances have been increasing over the years. It is up the Minister of Justice as to when they get released – the judiciary have no input in that.
http://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/why-does-life-now-mean-a-much-longer-sentence-1.1857296
“In Ireland, a life sentence prisoner can expect to spend 22 years in prison. This is in marked contrast to the single-digit figures served by such offenders in the 1970s.
Ireland has now surpassed England and Wales in terms of time served. The relatively consistent approach to time served by murderers in England and Wales over the last decade ( 14 to 17 years) is in stark contrast to the increases in Ireland (from 11 to 22 years).”
The newspaper article you’re quoting is an opinion piece. The CSO figures also clearly illustrate a wide range of time served which in itself indicates a considerable variable in the likely length of time you’ll spend in prison, thus mitigating the effects of a mandatory ‘life’ sentence. Also, the numbers of convictions for ‘life’ sentences is considerably less than those for other serious offences where someone has been killed, like manslaughter or dangerous driving causing death.
So on the whole, it’s not a great article to quote. It’s fairly weak in fact, and it’s mostly opinion rather than fact (albeit with a few facts thrown in).
The fact remains that when you look at all prison sentences where someone was killed, then the likelihood is that you will serve single digit years. Sentencing should be a lot more harsher in Ireland; especially where you take the life of another person.
But you cannot compare manslaughter with murder. Manslaughter covers a much wider range of crimes. A single punch after a loud drunken argument where both sides have been aggressive can lead to death. That is manslaughter but it is not the same as pre-meditate killing and in such circumstances a suspended sentence may be the correct decision. Sometimes terrible things happen and they are by awful chance and not intended.
I understand where you are coming from, and I wasn’t suggesting that we compare manslaughter with murder. The two points I was trying to draw attention to were (1) that on ‘life’ sentencing alone there is a considerable variable in ‘Life’ sentencing which suggests a wide range of application of the term ‘life’ to a sentence and thus reduces what a ‘life’ sentence actually is. And (2) that if you include, not compare but include other sentences where a life has been lost that the overall figure of prison sentencing means that the number comes down to single digits.
I’m a great believer in the likes of broken windows’ theory and of restorative justice, and dare I say it, but suspended sentencing is a useful thing in the right circumstances. But I’m personally of the believe that if you take another’s life as a result of your actions that you should then be put in prison for the rest of your life. I do not see any natural justice or common justice in having one person six feet under and their family handed a lifetime of pain, and for the other person(s) to be left free after X amount of time. There are tragic occurrences, as you mentioned like one punch incidents, but a life has been lost forever as the result of another’s chosen actions. I personally feel there needs to be an accountable responsibility to ones actions. I may well be alone in thinking that however.
Very sad.
Victoria looks like a lovely person, a gentle soul.
She did not deserve to die like that.
From previous information relating to the couple she was far from gentle however nobody deserves to be murdered.
Am so happy that at list we could meet a man for help who will generously help us without any delay my name is Anthony Jordan am from USA,am just here to share this wonderful testimony for what this great man called DR DR OKOKH has done for me i really love my family especially my wife but i don’t know why just decided to leave me without no reason we have been dating for the past 4 years and planning on getting married she just told me that she is not sure if she can continue with this relationship which i then told her that why she said she is tired of me and then i just believe she was meeting another guy and this guy has blind folded her immediately i knew this i tried to search for help which then i recollected about one faithful day when i was watching a program on the TV about how people got help from DR OKOKH so then went to search about DR DR OKOKH which then i got his details and i emailed him which then i had to share my problem with him he just told me not to worry that he assures me that my lover would be back to my arms within 24 hours believe me am so happy within the 24 hours i got back my love she came to apologise to me telling me she never knew what came over her i accepted her back to my life am so happy all thanks to DR OKOKH and you can contact him for help on,obohokokrspellcaster@gmail.com
Hello to every one out here, am here to shear my the unexpected miracle that has happen to me three days ago,I came across a post online talking about how she got her ex back to her with the help of the great spell caster who happens to be high Dr akugbe, that he helped her though i never believe this because i was just wondering how could this be, but i gave my self hope and i contact the spell caster.this is the unbelievable that has happened to me this apiral I was happily married and we had three kids, we lived together as one because we both loved each other but before i knew it,my husband started acting funny and cheating on me later on,he told me that he cannot continue with me again i was confuse, so that was how he left me and my three kids without noting but there was noting i could do to stop him or bring him back to me I work so had to pay the children’s schools fee and other responsibility i did this for good five years. I cry all day and night because i don’t know what else to do to have my husband back to me until this faithful day i saw the post from one miss Nicole testifying how the high priest helped her to get her ex back I just wanted to try my luck because i never believe it will work but to my greatest surprise,am singing a new song i contacted the great priest on 2nd of march and he told me not to worry because once he finish caster the spell, that i should not worry i will get my husband back, the unbelievable happened on Friday when i got a call and I was surprise to hear my husbands voice apologizing to me that he is so sorry for keeping alone and came back home and we are happy together again wow, i really appreciate your good work great Dr ehige, God bless you and your good work for there noting else i can say than to tell the world about you.So if any one is out here seeing this post and you have similar issue like this, worry no more and contact the only man that can help you this email: allmightbazulartemple@gmail.com
My name is: post buy Samantha
have your say