ELON MUSK HAS claimed that Irish citizens receive longer prison sentences than foreigners in a post on his social media site, X, where he has 211 million followers.
Musk has been posting repeatedly in the last two weeks about a scandal involving grooming gangs of mostly British-Pakistani men that rocked the UK more than ten years ago and has re-emerged as a political issue recently.
Yesterday, he briefly turned his attention towards sexual crimes committed in Ireland, pointing to the case of an asylum seeker who was convicted of rape over 20 years ago as evidence of “illegal immigrants” getting shorter prison sentences than Irish people.
His claim even made the front page of The Irish Examiner this morning.
In a post on X last Wednesday, Elon Musk said: “Irish citizens get longer sentences than illegal immigrants. That’s messed up.”
Musk, a new member of incoming US president Donald Trump’s inner circle, was retweeting a post from an Irish account that regularly shares hateful diatribes against Muslims and immigrants, as well as misinformation and conspiracy theories.
Irish citizens get longer sentences than illegal immigrants. That’s messed up. https://t.co/ck1Mgq6SbP
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) January 8, 2025
The original post began:
“For over 20 years, Muslim illegal immigrants have been handed lesser sentences for raping women in Ireland.”
That post contained images of an Irish Independent article from May 2003 that reported the sentencing of an Algerian asylum seeker who was found guilty of rape and oral rape.
Sid Ahmed Benflici was sentenced to ten years in prison but the judge, who described him as “a serial rapist” because of a previous conviction for kidnapping and raping a teenager, suspended the final 18 months of the sentence due to Benflici’s early guilty plea.
The post by @Mick_O_Keeffe also contained an image of an Irish Independent article about Benflici’s previous conviction in 2001, with an arrow highlighting a quote from the judge in that case, who said: “If you were an Irish man, or resident here, you would have been jailed for 10 years.”
Benflici received a six-year sentence instead.
In this case, judge Robert Barr said an Irish prison would be difficult and particularly alien environment for a foreigner like Benflici.
The original poster and Elon Musk have pointed to this quote from a judge in a case that is more than 20 years old in order to claim that “illegal immigrants” – a non-existent legal category – get lighter sentences than Irish citizens.
So, is it true?
Data related to the religious faith or immigration status of sex offenders in not publicly available in Ireland, so it is not possible to analyse the sentencing of Muslim immigrants compared with Irish citizens.
Additionally, “illegal immigrant” is not a classification that exists in Irish law, so a comparison of the kind Musk is suggesting is not possible to begin with.
However, research published in April 2022 by the Irish Penal Reform Trust (IPRT) found that foreign nationals and people from minority ethnic backgrounds receive significantly longer sentences than white Irish people for drug offences and sex offences.
When it comes to other offences, the research found no statistical differences in sentencing.
The report, which was funded by the Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission (IHREC) and produced by a team of researchers from the Maynooth University School of Law and Criminology, looked at data provided by the Irish Prison Service.
It found that foreign nationals received sentences for sexual offences that were on average 15.9 months longer than those handed down to Irish people.
People with an ethnicity other than white who were found guilty of sexual offences received sentences that were an average of 32 months longer than white people.
The research by the IPRT was the first of its kind in Ireland, and also found that ethnic minorities and foreign nationals were overrepresented in the Irish prison system.
The IPRT also found that foreign national and minority ethnic groups in Ireland’s prisons experience significant challenges, including discrimination by both staff and inmates.
Judges in Ireland are able to exercise discretion when sentencing offenders and can choose to reduce or increase a sentence for a number of reasons, including mitigating or aggravating factors and guilty pleas.
According to Molly Joyce, IPRT’s acting executive director at the time, the disproportionate number of foreigners and minorities in Irish prisons “could indicate potential bias in the criminal justice system”, but “the lack of comprehensive data collection by State agencies means we cannot be sure, nor can we more thoroughly examine these apparent disparities”.
“This is yet another example where deficient data leads to a fundamental lack of understanding of the situation, which in turn inevitably leads to deficient responses,” Joyce said.
Musk’s claim mirrors one being pushed by far-right groups and politicians in the UK, who say the country has a “two-tier” policing system that discriminates against white people.
Among those pushing the claim was Reform UK leader Nigel Farage. Musk has branded UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer “two-tier Keir”.
That push from Farage and other right-wing actors came in the aftermath of the racist, Islamophobic riots that shook parts of England and Northern Ireland last summer and led to hundreds of arrests.
The same claim has resurfaced in recent weeks since the grooming gang scandal was brought back to the fore of UK politics.
Elon Musk said that Irish citizens receive longer prison sentences than what he termed “illegal immigrants”.
He made the claim while boosting a social media post that pointed to a single quote from a judge in a rape trial in 2003 as evidence.
In that case, the judge suspended 18 months of a ten-year sentence because he believed prison would be a difficult and particularly alien environment for the offender, an asylum seeker from Algeria.
However, this story belies the reality at a system-wide level.
To date, the only research into disparities in sentencing between foreigners and Irish people found the opposite to be true.
A 2022 report by the Irish Penal Reform Trust, which was produced by a team of researchers from the Maynooth University School of Law and Criminology, looked at data provided by the Irish Prison Service.
It found that foreign nationals received sentences for sexual offences that were on average 15.9 months longer than those handed down to Irish people. It found a similar disparity when it came to drug offences.
Therefore, we find Elon Musk’s claim that Irish citizens receive longer prison sentences than foreign nationals to be FALSE. As per our verdict guide, this means the claim is inaccurate.
The Journal’s FactCheck is a signatory to the International Fact-Checking Network’s Code of Principles. You can read it here. For information on how FactCheck works, what the verdicts mean, and how you can take part, check out our Reader’s Guide here. You can read about the team of editors and reporters who work on the factchecks here.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
have your say