Advertisement

We need your help now

Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.

You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.

If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.

Ian Bailey Leah Farrell/RollingNews.ie

'I'm pleased and delighted': High Court refuses to extradite Ian Bailey to France

Authorities in France sought the surrender of the Cork man for the alleged voluntary homicide of French woman Sophie Toscan du Plantier.

Updated 2.19pm

THE HIGH COURT has refused to order the extradition of Ian Bailey to France in relation to the death of Sophie Toscan du Plantier, dismissing the Minister for Justice’s application as an “abuse of process”, among other reasons.

Mr Bailey (60) of The Prairie, Liscaha, Schull, west Cork, denies any involvement in the death of Tuscan du Plantier, who was found dead outside her holiday home in Schull in December 1996.

French authorities previously sought the surrender of Bailey in 2010 but this application was refused by the Supreme Court in 2012. A second extradition request was transmitted to Ireland last summer, seeking the surrender of Bailey for alleged voluntary homicide.

French authorities have, in the past, prosecuted people for crimes committed against French citizens outside of France. Bailey, who claims gardaí tried to frame him for the killing of the French woman, could be tried in France in his absence.

Refusing the surrender of Bailey today, Justice Tony Hunt said the minister was “estopped” or halted from obtaining an order for Bailey’s surrender in light of the Supreme Court’s judgment in 2012 on identical relevant facts.

Justice Hunt said he would also refuse surrender because, in the unique circumstances of this case, it was an “abuse of process” for five distinct reasons for the minister to seek surrender on the fresh warrant.

‘Delighted’

Speaking outside court, Bailey said: “I tend not to have reactions to this long ongoing ordeal. Obviously I’m pleased and delighted with the judgement of the judge today and I thank judge Hunt for that judgment. I would also thank my legal team who have been amazing.”

“It’s not the end of it because the State will almost certainly appeal that decision today. It’s noticeable that the State who took this case against me and have put me through a form of torture for 20 years on-and-off, were not even represented in court today. There was nobody there, which is astonishing.”

“Later this week we get a decision on whether I have a new civil appeal. That’s happening on Wednesday.”

“I would think the State would almost certainly appeal this decision today so it’s not the end of the matter.”

He said he did not know if the French would go ahead with a trial in his absence. When asked if he had a message to the French, Bailey said: “I have always said, I’m very sympathetic to the family and I know that they believe for whatever reason that I had something to do with the death of their daughter. And I’m very sympathetic, but I had nothing to do with it. I can’t say very much more than that.”

‘No way around’

Justice Hunt, in his judgement, said he did not need a reference to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), as had been requested by the State. He said the minister and his successors were “disappointed litigants” and it appeared to him that the underlying theme of the minister’s application was a “conviction that the majority of the Supreme Court were in error” in 2012.

A five-judge panel of the Supreme Court refused to surrender Bailey in 2012 and four of the five judges upheld Bailey’s argument that section 44 prohibits surrender because the alleged offence was committed outside French territory and Irish law does not allow prosecution for the same offence when committed outside its territory by a non-Irish citizen.

Opposing surrender at a High Court hearing in May, counsel for Bailey, Garrett Simons SC, said there was “no way around” the Supreme Court decision in 2012.

Simons said section 44 of the European Arrest Warrant Act 2003, which implemented the European Framework Decision on extradition between member states, was determined by the Supreme Court as an “absolute bar” to Bailey’s surrender and that that bar continued to apply.

Five reasons

In a written judgment handed down today, Hunt said he believed the application should be dismissed an abuse of process for five reasons.

Firstly, he said there was the binding and conclusive decision of the Supreme Court on the extra-territoriality issue.

Secondly, five years had passed since that decision and it was now 21 years since the death of Sophie Toscan du Plantier.

Apparently, neither the Minister nor the French authorities considered it appropriate to furnish “any information by way of explanation” for the elapse of time, Justice Hunt said. “I do not know when or why Mr Bailey” moved from being a suspect to “a person required for prosecution.”

Thirdly, there had been no engagement by the minister of the French authorities with the “unusual fact in an extradition case” that Bailey’s alleged involvement in the death of Tuscan du Plantier had been “comprehensively and repeatedly investigated and considered by the police force and prosecuting authorities” in Ireland.

The DPP “concluded long ago that there is no basis for either (a) charge or trial on this matter in this jurisdiction, and unusually, a comprehensive statement of reasons for this prosecutorial decision came into the public domain during the previous Supreme Court proceedings”.

Neither the warrant nor the Minister’s application for surrender “engages with this situation at all”.

“It is simply suggested by the minister that such matters are not relevant to the surrender request. I am unable to share this sanguine viewpoint,” Justice Hunt said, adding that this was a “significant omission”.

“In effect, proceedings were issued for the involuntary surrender of a person entitled to the protection of our laws and Constitution” for a trial and possible imprisonment for 30 years, “ignoring or regarding as irrelevant” the comprehensive determination by Ireland’s domestic legal process that the allegation giving rise to the request could not justify “the preferment of a charge, let alone trial and conviction”.

“I believe I am entitled to regard this highly unusual state of affairs as a contribution to a finding of abuse of process in this case,” Justice Hunt said.

Fourthly, even if it were subsequently decided that the Supreme Court was wrong, it was “highly debatable” whether that would result in the rendition of Bailey and the “forfeiture” of the earlier ruling in his favour.

Fifthly, Justice Hunt said he considered the “conduct” of the first proceedings. He said the “tactical decision to proceed on all fronts, notwithstanding manifest difficulties … makes the current position of the minister untenable.”

“These proceedings amount to no more than abelated and direct challenge to that outcome (in the Supreme Court).”

“In the absence of any material change of circumstances … and unless and until the Supreme Court agrees it fell into error in the manner in which section 44 was interpreted, I cannot regard proceedings issued in such circumstances as other than an abuse of process of this (High) Court.”

“Such a conclusion will not be reached lightly in extradition litigation, but the unique features of this case justify termination of the process on this basis at this time”.

Still bound to follow Supreme Court interpretation

Furthermore, he said the doctrine of precedent also disposed of the matter in Bailey’s favour. The principle that the High Court follows the Supreme Court “is so long established that it rarely requires expression”.

He said the binding effect of the Supreme Court decision on legal issues went beyond the parties to or facts of the case. In the unlikely event the High Court was faced with a surrender request involving different people in identical circumstances, the High Court would still be bound to follow the Supreme Court’s interpretation and application of section 44.

In relation to “issue estoppel”, Justice Hunt said there was no reason to exempt extradition proceedings from the rationale that public policy required a definite and decisive end to litigation.

There was the same interest in finality and certainty in relation to outcomes, and the need for parties and courts to avoid “being vexed repeatedly with issues previously and conclusively decided as between the same parties”.

He said the second warrant was different and must be assessed individually but the Minister could not point to any relevant change in legal or factual circumstances which would allow the High Court to take a different view of the extra-territoriality issue.

Justice Hunt said he did not consider it necessary to obtain the opinion of the European Court, as had been requested by the Minister.

The judge said it appeared to him that the “theme underlying” the minister’s second extradition application was “a conviction that the majority of the Supreme Court were in error in deciding the previous application in the manner they did”.

“Unlike most disappointed litigants, the minister and his successors had the power to amend the legal position applicable” to that ruling if it was “genuinely felt the Supreme Court had incorrectly interpreted” section 44 in the light of the framework decision, “as was submitted by the Minster in this case”.

“No steps had been taken in that direction. Instead, the minister now seeks to take advantage of the fact that a reference tot he Court of Justice of the European Union in relation to the interpretation of the Framework Decision is now possible from the Irish courts.”

“It is suggested the earlier interpretation (by the Supreme Court) could be overturned (by the European Court)” if a preliminary reference to the European Court resulted in an opinion which suggested that “the Supreme Court was in error”.

Justice Hunt said the correct interpretation of the national provision has been “specifically, finally and conclusively determined in proceedings between the same parties by a court whose decisions are “final and conclusive” under the Constitution”.

“An assertion that the Supreme Court incorrectly decided the previous case does not permit the High Court to proceed to adopt the minority view. If that were the position, the work of the courts would expand exponentially and no legal advice could be offered with any degree of certainty.”

Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.

View 83 comments
Close
83 Comments
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Paolo Fandango
    Favourite Paolo Fandango
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:26 AM

    There is this amazing new technology called ‘text messaging’. I think it’s scientific secret code name is SMS

    Some say it could be a game changer for when you want to send a short text based communique to a person who also owns a ‘mobile phone’

    Can’t see it catching on myself to be honest.

    231
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute transik
    Favourite transik
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 11:33 AM

    @Paolo Fandango: buddy i will buy you a pint. Today . If you show me how to text video or photo.your turn.

    31
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute David Reilly
    Favourite David Reilly
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 11:37 AM

    @transik: MMS

    116
    See 12 more replies ▾
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Alan Kenny
    Favourite Alan Kenny
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 11:53 AM

    @transik: Most Text apps now you can send photos, GIFs, Videos. I do it all the time.

    26
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Paolo Fandango
    Favourite Paolo Fandango
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 1:11 PM

    @transik: unless you’re using a Nokia 3310, this is already a feature of your phones native messaging abilities.

    Where we getting that pint then?

    44
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Bri Lyons
    Favourite Bri Lyons
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 1:26 PM

    @transik: you can txt photo .. it’s called mms

    15
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Ashling Fenton
    Favourite Ashling Fenton
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 1:40 PM

    @Paolo Fandango: Jesus at what point did the youth forget what an SMS and MMS are?!!!!

    18
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Alan
    Favourite Alan
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 1:41 PM

    @Paolo Fandango: have one on me… https://images.app.goo.gl/9xJbem3ygJGS4Yng9

    2
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Diarmuid Hunt
    Favourite Diarmuid Hunt
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 1:47 PM

    @Ashling Fenton: I doubt the youth have forgotten, just never encountered it or had the need for it.

    8
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Paolo Fandango
    Favourite Paolo Fandango
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 2:12 PM

    @Alan: if the pints at your local are that good then let’s find a comfy perch and sink a good skin full.

    6
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Cat K.
    Favourite Cat K.
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 2:23 PM

    @Paolo Fandango: Many people don’t have free texts and rely on WhatsApp or other online messaging platforms

    10
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Paolo Fandango
    Favourite Paolo Fandango
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 3:58 PM

    @Cat K. Indeed, as you say there are other messaging platforms. They didn’t all go down today. Just WhatsApp.

    And if you didn’t have free texts then the simple solution is to buy some phone credit.

    2
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute UK Hurling Bloke
    Favourite UK Hurling Bloke
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 4:28 PM

    @transik: you’re gonna be buying a lot of pints buddy

    4
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Fiona Fitzgerald
    Favourite Fiona Fitzgerald
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 6:56 PM

    @Paolo Fandango: Not to mention that if you’re offline or out of data, you can still text!

    1
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Fiona Fitzgerald
    Favourite Fiona Fitzgerald
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 6:58 PM

    @Cat K.: loads of websites offer free texting, as I discovered as a skint student.

    1
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute aidan mccormack
    Favourite aidan mccormack
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:09 AM

    Its mad, You don’t realise how much you use it until its not working.

    165
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Justin Gillespie
    Favourite Justin Gillespie
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:23 AM

    @aidan mccormack: Back to the old payphone with the A & B buttons.

    121
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Aunties
    Favourite Aunties
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:54 AM

    @aidan mccormack: it’s BACK !!!

    17
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Seanie Bourke
    Favourite Seanie Bourke
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:19 AM

    Wats my bebo password again

    86
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute The Thinker
    Favourite The Thinker
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:22 AM

    @Seanie Bourke: Bebo, Ireland’s own social media page

    17
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Colm Connolly
    Favourite Colm Connolly
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 2:07 PM

    @The Thinker: you know it wasn’t irish it just seemed like the Irish were the only ones to use it

    12
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute SquideyeMagpie
    Favourite SquideyeMagpie
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:10 AM

    Those sneaky f-ing Russians

    92
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Mattress Dick
    Favourite Mattress Dick
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:27 AM

    I was going to share this article but …

    30
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Aunties
    Favourite Aunties
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:35 AM

    @Mattress Dick: lol (insert emoji)

    15
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Max Power
    Favourite Max Power
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 10:13 AM

    We need more data centers so this won’t happen again.

    27
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Dr. Emmett Lathrop Brown
    Favourite Dr. Emmett Lathrop Brown
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:15 AM

    OMG, how am I going to survive the day, back my Bulletin Board System :)

    20
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Kieran Stafford
    Favourite Kieran Stafford
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 10:13 AM

    Whatsup?

    17
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Aunties
    Favourite Aunties
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:37 AM

    Can I communicate with my fantasy football group on the Journal comment section ?

    17
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Paolo Fandango
    Favourite Paolo Fandango
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:40 AM

    @Aunties: Ah steve. I’ve told you time and time again to take out Ronaldo. Let go of his past and realise he’s not gonna help you.

    33
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Earth Traveller
    Favourite Earth Traveller
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 2:17 PM

    My thoughts and prayers are with those who were affected. This is clearly the government’s fault. I hope Whatsapp users are receiving the support they need.

    13
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Aidy McBride
    Favourite Aidy McBride
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:59 AM

    Mick Dundee didn’t need any of this nonsense

    20
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Steve O'Hara-Smith
    Favourite Steve O'Hara-Smith
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:09 AM

    Time to go back to IRC – nobody owned that.

    11
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Nor Doherty
    Favourite Nor Doherty
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 1:12 PM

    goes to show how too many are addicted to it I don’t be on it constantly 2 hours too little I say

    9
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Appaddy
    Favourite Appaddy
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 10:42 AM

    It is working in Spain

    3
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Aunties
    Favourite Aunties
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:42 AM

    Haaland or Salah trips captain ?!? What u think Freddy

    3
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Don Hogan
    Favourite Don Hogan
    Report
    Oct 25th 2022, 9:10 PM

    VIBER

    1
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Tacita O'Copa
    Favourite Tacita O'Copa
    Report
    Oct 26th 2022, 3:32 AM

    The Guardia Civil are un poco sarcástico.

    1
    Install the app to use these features.
    Mute Tacita O'Copa
    Favourite Tacita O'Copa
    Report
    Oct 26th 2022, 3:33 AM

    sarcástico

    1
Submit a report
Please help us understand how this comment violates our community guidelines.
Thank you for the feedback
Your feedback has been sent to our team for review.
JournalTv
News in 60 seconds