Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
THE CONSTRUCTION OF the new children’s hospital on the St James’ site is to begin “within a matter of weeks” according to the Minister of Health Simon Harris.
The new hospital, which was signed off by the minister at today’s Cabinet meeting, will be open by 2021.
The building will have 380 single rooms, all with en-suite bathrooms and a parent’s bed. There will be 93 daycare beds, 22 operating theatres (an increase of 40% on theatre capacity at present) and 122 consulting rooms.
The accommodation includes inpatient rooms for neonatology intensive care, as well as 20 child and adolescent mental health beds for patients with eating disorders and acute mental health services for children.
In addition, there will be a hospital school, a third level research facility, and specialist therapy and play facilities for children.
Works to begin on site
The hospital site will have four acres of green space – including a ‘rainbow garden’ which is a central feature of the design, and a ‘meadow garden’.
Harris said he was “delighted” and “proud” to make the final announcement today that works can now begin on the site.
He said the “sheer scale” of the development cannot be underestimated.
As big as Dundrum Shopping Centre
“We are building a hospital that will be the length of Grafton Street and the size of Dundrum Shopping Centre – this is great day for the health service,” said Harris, who has been under pressure this week due to the details surrounding the ownership of the new National Maternity Hospital.
This is an issue that has been debated in this country for a long number of years. This is an issue that government comes and government goes and people have constantly wondered when we are going to get on with building the national children’s hospital, and providing facilities for children and their families that they so badly need and deserve in this country.
He said the new hospital, which will amalgamate services at Crumlin, Temple Street and Tallaght hospitals, will “revolutionise” how children’s healthcare is delivered in Ireland.
However, there have been criticisms of the hospital’s site by parent groups, such as Connolly for Kids, who believe a more suitable greenfield site can be found on the outskirts of the city along the M50.
The group argues that many parents and children who must avail of the services are coming from all around the country, and maintain the St James’ site is needlessly dragging them into the busy city centre.
When asked about the criticisms, the minister said the St James’ site is the most suitable based on medical reasons.
‘Children can wait no longer’
Harris said the children of Ireland can’t wait any longer for the new hospital.
“We have to get on and build this,” he said.
Being in politics and being in government is about making decisions. You have to get to the point after consulting and debating, after the Oireachtas voting on it, after the previous government deciding on the location, after many, many people having an opinion on the site – you get to the point where you’ve got to press go. We cannot wait any longer to build this hospital.
The new children’s hospital (whose official name is still under wraps) will cost over €1.07 billion to build.
The cost has been a contentious issue, but the minister today denied that the budget had spiralled out of control.
Underestimating the cost
“Yes, we are spending more on this than originally envisaged. The original was about €650m in 2014, that has evolved over time,” he said.
“We are doing an awful lot more than was estimated in that figure – we did not include the hospital school, the third level research centre, the retail and the parking. It didn’t include the equipping and it certainly didn’t include making this Ireland’s first digital hospital,” he said.
The increase in cost is also being blamed on construction inflation, which officials claim has risen from 3% in 2014 to 9%.
The market costs of the tenders also came in €40 million higher than forecast.
The cost breakdown
The current cost for the hospital comes in at €983 million in capital costs and €88 million for ICT costs in the hospital.
More than €1.004 billion is to come from Exchequer funding, while €67 million will come from commercial and philanthropic funding.
The hospital group tasked with delivering the project denied that it will be the most expensive hospital in Europe, stating that the costs have been benchmarked against other hospitals built in Europe, the US and the Middle East.
Though the names of the hospitals used in the benchmarking process were not provided for commercial reasons, the project designers and managers said the new children’s hospital comes in under the average cost of other hospitals around the world.
The cost of the St James’ site children’s hospital costs €4,200 per square metre, while it costs an average of €4,700 in the US and €5,000 in the Middle East.
While the hospital group said it did not believe the cost per bed was an accurate reflection of value for money, it said the average cost in the hospital stands at just over €1 million per bed.
Is there anything not included in the cost?
Some of the funding for operational costs, such as training of staff, as well as some of the HSE ICT needed, is not included in the final figure.
The cost of staffing the hospital is also not included.
An additional 600 staff will be needed for the day-to day running of the children’s hospital.
Will this hospital be delivered on budget? Harris said it has to be.
“I expect, and the government expects, for this to come in on budget and on time,” said Harris.
I suspect Johnson may emerge from his vaccine lap ahead, scornfully glancing at the EU, by forcing an early election while branding Labour a bunch of chickens if they initially resist – and then forging ahead with the Tory majority extended from 80 to 100 or so.
And then if there’s a hot Summer of protest up North he’ll play the great statesman by calling for the Northern Ireland protocol to be scrapped or unilaterally scrapping it, in an effort to strategically weaken Ireland’s relationship with the EU, while contently watching whether there’ll be a land border as a result.
I think we might well be in for a few more laughs with this joker.
@Mick Tobin: Am no fan of the yanks but we might need them to put the pressure on the UK re a trade deal if you’re right.
I should perhaps add that Johnson might also want to consider renaming his party the ENP – the English National Party.
@Mick Tobin: it’s unreal how quite Labour are. They really need to kick in with something solid soon.
@Paul Furey: They can’t, there’s absolutely b***** all they can do at the moment. They tried moving to the hard left under Corbyn – seemingly an effort to move away from Blair which already started with Ed Miliband, and that obviously didn’t work.
Now they’re back at the centre and all they can do is wait until the corona crisis is over, and it’s back to the everyday realities including those of Brexit. Then perhaps they have a shot at coming up with a few viable alternatives (such as joining the customs union).
I think for one they need another leader, perhaps Manchester mayor Andy Burnham. In any case I’m afraid it’ll be a long time before they have a serious chance at winning an election.
@Mick Tobin: You are hypothesising my worst fears. He is a deplorable joke of a man with zero integrity, morals. His political and career ambitions trumps anything like an international peace treaty such as the GFA. There will be terrible consequences for the UK but if the terds amplify scenes like week he could have his excuse.
@Gary Garden: In a sense Johnson is simply a representative of the usual confrontational divide-and-conquer style of British politics – albeit a more serious case. But Brexit has made it spill over onto the international stage, with Ireland the first scapegoat to be encountered there.
@Mick Tobin: you had me at ‘joker’… spoiled it with this prejudiced postscript. Shame.
@Paul Furey:
Since Corbyn was shafted there is no opposition, Starmer is Tory light, just like Blair.
Same happened here with Labour becoming FG Light.
No opposition in the UK and only SF as opposition here with PBP, SD and a few others.
Awful Shame everyone has shifted to the Right
@Mick Tobin: an nationalist leader, Ireland would benefit greatly from one
For a small Irish newspaper to infer that the British prime minister is some sort of circus character is a bit rich considering what you have for a government in Ireland.
@Michael Maher: the guardian is not Irish, it started in Manchester & it has become a laughable shadow of its former self.
@Richard Cronin: The Journal took up on it
@Michael Maher: this is journal most of the articles on here are copy & paste jobs from associated press (American). That don’t make it irish, it makes journal a poor news site that is why most people come on here for the comments.
@Richard Cronin: 100%
He is certainly no mug.
@Scott Coulter: he is actually. He’s out of his depth. He wanted the lead role in his school, he got and hadn’t a clue what to do. He wanted the
He is Penny wise and Pound……
A very good read. Unfortunately we have a government who is not performing like Johnson but by their actions, have inadvertently become clowns. Everything they touch at the moment is falling apart. These clowns are not giving us anything to laugh at and the audience are far from happy.
have your say