Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
THERE HAS BEEN no improvement in mental healthcare for Ireland’s prison population over the past year and there is particular concern about waiting lists for those due to be transferred to the Central Mental Hospital, according to a new report.
There were 29 prisoners awaiting transfer to the mental hospital in Dundrum, Dublin at the end of April 2019, the Irish Penal Reform Trust’s (IPRT) annual report shows.
Executive director of IPRT Fíona Ní Chinnéide said it is disappointing that there hasn’t been a reduction in the numbers of people in prison with acute mental illness awaiting transfer to the Central Mental Hospital (CMH) over the last three years.
“People with severe mental health issues cannot wait for the opening of the new facility at Portrane in 2020, so it is important that there is a declared commitment, as well as clear accountability in terms of reducing waiting lists for the CMH, and for diverting people experiencing mental illness from the prison system.”
‘Full capacity’
People who have been found not guilty by reason of insanity after a trial, or those in the prison system who have been diagnosed with severe psychological conditions by psychiatrists are transferred to the CMH.
This week a mother who smothered her three-year-old daughter with a pillow was found not guilty by reason of insanity.
Yesterday the court was told the woman could not be committed to the Central Mental Hospital on Wednesday because the facility had reached “full capacity in its quota of female patients”.
A barrister for the HSE told the Central Criminal Court that every effort was being made to secure a bed for the woman and it was hoped that the matter would be resolved by this morning. The judge in the case vacated her committal order and released her on bail until a bed can be made available at the hospital.
In May, a judge in Ennis, Co Clare, criticised the State’s failure to locate a placement for a man who had been found not guilty of arson by reason of insanity.
At that time, counsel for the State told the judge that there were 48 people waiting for a place at the CMH.
Twenty-five-year-old Ross Malone was in Limerick prison at the time due to the unavailability of beds at the mental hospital. Judge Gerald Keys said the State is “duty bound under our constitution to provide these facilities and they are not doing it”.
It is not good enough to say that there are no resources. All you have to do is read in the newspaper that we have had €7 billion of a windfall on savings in relation to the exchequer. I get no pleasure having to say these things, but there is frustration just building up all the time in relation to resources in the criminal justice system.
Waiting times
The IPRT report states the hospital is currently operating at 100% of its capacity with admissions “systematically triaged according to the level of therapeutic security required and the urgency of clinical need”.
The average waiting time for transfer from the prison to CMH is 120 days, with a range from seven to 504 days. The IPRT has said the new facility planned for Portrane next year, which will have a maximum capacity for 170 patients, will “not meet demand based on the current and persistent number of prisoners awaiting transfer”.
General mental health services for prisoners across the country is also an issue of concern, according to the trust.
A recent Irish Prison Service (IPS) study on self-harm in prisons found there were 223 incidents between 1 January and 31 December 2017. An episode of self-harm was recorded for 4% of the prison population and the majority of these prisoners were male.
Last year an inquest into the death of a man by suicide at Cork Prison heard evidence that 15-minute checks required for prisoners on ‘special observation’ had not been carried out. IPS procedures were changed following the inquest.
The IPRT said the psychologist-prisoner ratios are “poor for much of the prison population”, with the lowest found in Castlerea (one counsellor to every 170 prisoners) and Cloverhill (one counsellor to ever 431 prisoners) prisons.
“Cloverhill is the main remand facility; as already noted, there is a high prevalence of mental health issues among the remand population, with previous domestic research having shown rates of psychosis to be among the highest for the remand population, at 7.6%,” the report states.
Cross-agency approach
There are currently 614 prisoners on a waiting list for an intervention from psychology services.
“The serious issues of prisoner numbers and access to mental health services while in prison can’t be solved by the Department of Justice and Equality or any one organisation alone,” Fíona Ní Chinnéide commented.
She said a cross-agency approach is needed with input from the judiciary, legislators and multiple departments, as well as the HSE and An Garda Síochána.
“We have been working closely with many of these organisations since the publication of the first Progress in the Penal System report in 2017 and hope that the short-term actions identified in today’s report will be considered and progressed by the relevant stakeholders.
“We all have the same vision: that of Ireland having a world-class penal system and becoming a leading model of international best practice.”
Need help? Support is available:
With reporting by Gordon Deegan
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
I be more worried about their victims’ waiting times
Who is caring for/monitoring that woman while she is on bail?
Waiting time for mental health services for the general public is hugely long, why should prisoners be any different?
This government couldn’t care less about the mental health of its people.
@Carm(Orange Vampire): would you really want dangerous people becoming more unwell and even more dangerous! Stemming the progression at the earliest onset is in everyone’s best interest, prisoners and ours
@Jason: most prisoners are on a trajectory that the basic help provided through the prison services is not going to help long term
@Carm(Orange Vampire):
How is every single thing in this country a disaster/over crowded/under funded/long waiting lists etc etc?
Why can nothing run smoothly?
A great little country for American multinationals and hedge funds and a lousy one for its citizens.
@Ronaldo Blanc: hear hear
@Ronaldo Blanc: If these American multinationals were not here we would still be going around on horse and cart and you would have nuns and priests running run down old dilapidated hellholes that nobody would dare visit…..who do you think are paying the bills?, the farmers lol…..kop on and think just a little before you point the finger. Its our rotten government that have the country a mess, them and their public service buddies and private sector criminals creaming every last drop out of the place….
@Ronaldo Blanc: It’s citizens are responsible for the mess they’re in because it’s citizens continue to vote the same degenerates in to govern them. People have to take responsibility for their actions and Irish voters are responsible for voting in the government. You can’t blame corrupt politicians for being corrupt when corruption is all they have demonstrated since the state came into existence. The blame falls squarely on the voters who continually put them in a position to exercise their corrupt ways and “cream every last drop out of the place”. So if Irish people want someone to blame for their woes they need only look in a mirror.
As for American multinationals; since we have no indigenous industry worth a mention we need to generate income some other way and this means prostituting ourselves out to whoever is willing to pay. Thanks to our corrupt politicians this has historically been American multinationals.
It’s not ok to not be ok in Ireland because Ireland inc can’t help you
@Tony Henry: Mental health is way down the government’s list of priorities and they don’t give a flying f***. Ask any parent of a child on a waiting list for a MH service and you’ll see. They just don’t care.
Would like to take issue with your headline of “prisoners with severe conditions” these are people with Mental Heath issues in dire need of Help where they should be classed as “patients” where the services they need are been Starved of resources
@Eamonn Tierney: while they are in prison they are still prisoners. If they move to the CMH they then become patients.
How is every single thing in this country a disaster/over crowded/under funded/long waiting lists etc etc?
Why can nothing run smoothly?
Typical Banana Republic Of Ireland!
An absolute joke of a country!
When the poor, the mentally ill and former prisoners begin to vote regularly, things will change. Politicians feel no pressure to protect these groups.
I was brought up very close to Dundrum ‘Asylum’ as it was called back then. It was a dark dank place to visit and a dangerous one. It was done up and improved but there is always the risk of a sudden burst of violence and some of these people are so ill, that they will kill. Hence not the nicest of environments to work in.
I believe that many political prisioners are psycopaths just as laypeople who are killers are and I believe in Ireland that Mental illness is way down the list of priorities infact a lot of funding has been taken away from Day Centres and call in centres which are preventative, but our Govt is longterm stupid and short term wise.
have your say