Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
Updated 15.55
A NEW WEBSITE PUTS power in the hands of churchgoers by letting them give instant feedback about their local priest.
The German site, called Hirten Barometer (or “Shepherd Barometer”) lets users class their hardworking cleric by a range of different attributes. Criteria include service to God, credibility, “finger on the pulse”, work for younger people and work for seniors. The average scores are represented as a sheep’s colour – with top priests turning bright white and underperformers a nasty black.
Andreas Hahn, one of the site’s founders, told Reuters that it aims to boost the quality of priests’ work as well as giving credit where due. “Pastoral work should be qualitative,” he said, adding: “Many parishes work well but their performance doesn’t become public.” He also said that he hopes the site will help to flag problem areas before they develop into something more serious. The site has registered 25,000 parishes and 8,000 priests so far.
Even deceased priests can be rated. So far, Pope John Paul II is a top performer in a light shade of grey, with users rating his service to the Lord especially highly. One anonymous user simply called him “A great Pope”. But there’s bad news for Benedict XVI should he happen to check the site out on his iPad – his “finger on the pulse” rating is letting him down. “There have been better Popes, like Johannes XXIII,” one user wrote.
The Irish Catholic Bishops’ Conference said they were not aware of the site. A spokesperson added: “It is already the case that the faithful offer and support their local parish priest and bishop.”
My vote goes to Fr Ted!
This is only the start of it , next they will probably begin their own music show and call it “top of the popes”
is this a “Hot or Not” page for the priests? WTF!
A picture of a sheep with a red rectal thermometer….mmmm does the sheep represent the church flock?????
Do they give a ‘totally pointless’ option?
Poor Holy Father! He is too old to be bereted by ungrateful German Sheep! I wonder how these sheep would “rate” as “Sheep” if the “Tables were turned around?”
Jesus said, “Judge not lest you be judged by the same measure you measure others.”
A pix
have your say