We need your help now
Support from readers like you keeps The Journal open.
You are visiting us because we have something you value. Independent, unbiased news that tells the truth. Advertising revenue goes some way to support our mission, but this year it has not been enough.
If you've seen value in our reporting, please contribute what you can, so we can continue to produce accurate and meaningful journalism. For everyone who needs it.
Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
By continuing, you are indicating that you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
TODAY, 1 OCTOBER is a public holiday in Hong Kong, as it is throughout China, ostensibly to celebrate the country’s National Day.
An occasion that is traditionally marked with a showcase fireworks display has been tempered this year by the Covid-19 pandemic, meaning that no mass gathering is allowed to take place.
It’s also the first National Day in five years that I will not be spending in Hong Kong.
After living and working as a journalist in the city since 2015, I left earlier this week following the Hong Kong government’s decision to decline my visa renewal application.
I am in no better position than any outside observer to speculate why this decision was made since no reason is typically given for such denials. It would also be audacious of me to compare my own circumstances to those of foreign correspondents who face the more challenging conditions that prevail in neighbouring mainland China.
In the past month, we’ve read accounts from Australian correspondents Bill Birtles and Michael Smith, who were forced to shelter at their country’s diplomatic premises while consular officials negotiated their safe exit from China.
Press freedom restricted
My own story is not a dramatic tale of escape. It was simply an administrative decision which meant I had to leave the city I had called home for five years. Yet the Hong Kong Immigration Department’s practice of not stating the reason for such decisions allows speculation to run wild, at a time when the city’s media freedoms are coming under increasing scrutiny with the recent passage of the national security law.
The law, which came into effect in June this year, calls on China’s representative offices in the city to work together with Hong Kong’s local government “to strengthen the management of and services for” foreign news organisations, but offers no specifics on what that means in practice.
In August, a police investigation into the foreign connections of media tycoon Jimmy Lai led to the dramatic images of hundreds of police officers conducting a search of a local newsroom.
Apple Daily, the newspaper whose offices were searched, is known for its vocal pro-opposition stance, which frequently puts it in confrontation with the local government.
New media, changing landscape
The changing environment for Hong Kong’s journalists covers more than just the staff from one partisan publication.
The sometimes-violent protests that rocked Hong Kong in the second half of 2019 were one of the biggest global news stories of the year, and attracted reporters from major news organisations worldwide, as well as citizen journalists with little more than a Facebook page on which to publish content.
They frequently converged in their dozens at scenes of conflict between police and protesters, leading Hong Kong’s police force to complain about “fake reporters” obstructing their work.
This led to a change of policy last month when the police force decided that, for the purposes of providing assistance at public events or issuing invitations to press conferences, it would only recognise journalists working for media organisations registered with the Hong Kong government, as well as renowned non-local organisations.
The full impact of the change, which effectively withdraws recognition of press passes issued by Hong Kong’s local journalist trade unions, remains unclear, but it is thought to create more risks for freelancers and students.
It has even led to fears that journalists who lack such recognition will be treated no differently to protesters by police officers on the ground. Public assurances from the Police Commissioner that the force respects press freedom will be tested at future events.
Major obstacles ahead
Elsewhere across Hong Kong’s media landscape, public concern remains at a high point. Irish people have always had a wide range of opinions about RTÉ’s editorial decisions, but it is generally accepted that such decisions are made without external pressure.
Meanwhile, Hong Kong’s public broadcaster, RTHK, earned a rebuke from a government minister in April over a current affairs programme in which a journalist asked a World Health Organization official about Taiwan’s future participation in the global health body.
The minister accused RTHK of breaching the principle of recognising Taiwan as a province of China, though the programme made no direct reference to Taiwan’s political status.
RTHK is now being subjected to a government-led review of its management systems, which is expected to be completed by the end of 2020. How the results of that review will affect RTHK’s editorial practices in the future will be anxiously watched by Hong Kong’s media community.
Hong Kong is a modern, first-world destination, and conditions for journalists in the city are not comparable to those that prevail in some of the world’s most troubled war zones and most controlled autocracies.
Yet Hong Kong’s placement on the RSF Press Freedom Index has fallen from #18 in 2002, when the 180-country index was first published, to #80 in 2020. The most recent ranking was published before the passage of the national security law, the full impact of which has only begun to be felt.
Already it has led to the arrests of protesters carrying signs with slogans deemed to be separatist, showing that published words are not beyond the reach of the new law. The question for Hong Kong’s journalists must surely be whether their published words will make them the next target.
Aaron Mc Nicholas is an Irish journalist who was based in Hong Kong from 2015 until 2020. He worked for Storyful news agency as well as Bloomberg during his time in the city and occasionally appears on RTÉ and BBC programmes providing news updates on Hong Kong. Twitter: @aaronMCN
WOW, all the pro-Chinese t-ro-lls already on here……..
I just read an utterly insane comment that HK protestors should be thankful they’re not facing the NYPD?!!
Just how blind to China’s, literal, decades long abuses of human rights do they think we are?
@Tricia G: the 50 cent army is always around for these articles to spout their muck.
It’s both Full Moon
@Seriousnojoke: You mean all those people being kettled in Causeway bay by Police right now?
@Seriousnojoke: You think people in HK should consider themselves lucky because they are not dealing with NYPD. I disagree, Hong Kongers are lucky because the CCP have been kind not send them to concentration camps like the have for the Uyghurs in mainland China.
@Seriousnojoke: Pro-PRC troll.
@Seriousnojoke: LMFAO
@Seriousnojoke: You are a CCP pansy. The police harrassed a senior citizen for carry a yellow balloon ffs and charge groups of people who gather to cross the street at crossings, then arrest minors for baseless charges. Reading an Apple daily publication gains you the attention of police, like the guy alone in the MTR surround by 12 or more police while he read the paper.
@Seriousnojoke: propaganda troll for the CCP.
@Little Pudding: “the CCP have been kind not send them to concentration camps like the have for the Uyghurs”
Give them time!
Move to Taiwan and report from there instead. That will really pi*s off the CCP.
25 years ago, I was worried about China for all of us…. kept saying that in several debates… here we are….
Apple Daily, full lies, bias views or opinions, we call it as poison Apple, just like Fox News, other media debunks their lies and nobody’s cares.
In hk, the journalist was cheap, just pay €25 that is all. The most time they have tons of “journalists” standing between police and riots, literally standing between them. The police couldn’t do their job, just like mosquitos, so annoying. One of the photo i’ve see is one police hold smoke grenade gun standing at the corner and aim, that is all on hk media, but the full photo is about 50 journalists around him and taking photo of him, who cares about that?
Denzel Washington said if you read the newspaper, if you don’t read it, you’re misinformed, What is the long-term effect of too much information? One of the effects is the need to be first, not even to be true anymore.”
So what a responsibility you all have; to tell the truth, not to just be first, but to tell the truth.
“We live in a society now where it’s just first. Who cares? Get it out there. We don’t care who it hurts, we don’t care who we destroy, we don’t care if it’s true. Just say it, sell it.”
Harrow
I had a comment deleted because I was critical of journalists and their of of the tv licence scam
have your say