Sign in. It’s quick, free and it’s up to you.
An account is an optional way to support the work we do. Find out more.
HEALTH MINISTER STEPHEN Donnelly has described the situation facing women who cannot access care for fatal foetal anomalies as “heartbreaking” following the release of a HSE study reviewing the 2019 abortion legislation.
Minster Donnelly said that he will be taking the testimony of the women surveyed as part of the research “very, very seriously”, and said that his “thoughts really go out” to those affected.
The Unplanned Pregnancy and Abortion Care study, led by Dr Catherine Conlon of Trinity College Dublin and commissioned by the HSE, found that current abortion legislation does not meet the needs of those seeking termination for foetal anomalies.
The research was shaped by the testimonies of 58 women who sought abortions between December 2019 and August 2021.
The review’s key findings highlight the difficulties faced by women living in rural areas in accessing services and restrictions within the Health (Regulation of Termination of Pregnancy) Act preventing women with foetal anomalies in accessing abortion services after 12 weeks of pregnancy.
“Women [find] themselves hoping for a ‘fatal enough’ diagnosis rather than being denied care and faced with travelling,” the report stated.
It also outlines the positive response among interviewees to the HSE’s unplanned pregnancy support service, My Options.
The research recommends that the Department of Health replace the mandatory three day waiting period with service provision based on one consultation, with an optional second consultation, and that abortion services be made available in all maternity hospitals.
The review also asks the Department of Health to re-evaluate the criminalisation aspect of the current legislation, whereby doctors cannot perform terminations outside of the criteria outlined in the Act.
Commenting on the research, Dr Conlon said: “From listening to the experiences of the 58 women we interviewed for this study it is clear that legalising abortion in Ireland has enhanced women’s well-being, dignity and autonomy. Provision of abortion care under 12 weeks’ gestation is working well and women reported quality, acceptable care from conscientious, committed providers.”
“Those seeking care regarding foetal anomaly, however, did not feel the service met their needs and described a protracted assessment process from which they felt heavily excluded.
“We know from international data that women continue to travel abroad to access abortion services and now our research illustrates how these women and their families feel let down, angry and bewildered at a time of acute loss and anguish,” she said.
Review
The study is just one of many submissions to the review of the current abortion legislation, which the Department of Health is obliged to carry out under section 7 of the 2018 Act within three years of commencement.
Speaking at the launch of Fianna Fáil’s women’s health policy, Minister Donnelly said that his department is “listening very carefully” to service users and service providers in the process of reviewing the current legislation.
The policy is a culmination of 103 commitments across the areas of reproductive, mental and physical health and seeks to provide more “tailored services for women of all ages”. It is backed by €31 million of ring fenced funding.
Its launch came just hours after the Health (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill, which seeks to provide free contraception for women aged 17-25, passed through all the stages of the Dáil, Minister Donnelly said.
The Health Minister also said that he submitted the General Scheme of a Bill to introduce safe access zones to protect women and staff from intimidation when entering healthcare facilities that provide abortion care for consideration to Cabinet, adding that he would love to see the legislation come into action “in this calendar year”.
“It’s a good day in terms of women’s health,” Minister Donnelly said.
“Women’s healthcare has never been invested in at the level that it should be. It’s never been prioritised the way that it should be.
“We have a dark history when it comes to women’s health care, particularly around women’s reproductive health. But I think we’re moving rapidly in the right direction.
“If [the Government] were able to achieve the progress across the entire healthcare system that we’re achieving in women’s health care, we’d be in a phenomenal place,” he said.
Under section 20 of the Health (Regulation of Termination of Pregnancy) Act 2018, the Minister is required no later than 30 June each year to prepare a report detailing the number of terminations carried out over the course of the preceding year.
The Minster is obliged to “lay this report before the Oireachtas as soon as practicable afterwards”.
The Journal understands that this report is completed and is expected to be presented to government tomorrow.
To embed this post, copy the code below on your site
For the spongers….. As if they don’t get enough!!! Maybe try get a job
@Kev Barnes: your a fool. Have you ever spoken to a genuine homeless person. You don’t no peoples life circumstances so don’t judge. Have a bit of compassion, it’s Christmas. This is not about people getting so called free houses, it’s about putting a smile on someone’s face. Crawl back into your hole
@Kev Barnes: most probably do have jobs. They are probably being paid minimum wage by billion euro companies. Working full time at minimum wage gives you around €380 a week. Average place in Dublin is around €1600. Even if both are working they would struggle to cover the rent. So the government step in and supplement this by way of our taxes. But of all the people you are pissed off with it’s the person not earning enough to cover their rent. They are at the mercy of their landlord with severe HAP discrimination. Most of them can’t afford to buy presents in fact most probably struggle to feed their families but I’m glad that the Christmas sprit is alive and well in you.
@Sos: it’s sad how someone can have such harsh views on children living in poverty. It’s not like the child asked to be born without the luxuries these people have.
@Ali Ní Dhomhnaill: I have actually I was homeless myself at one point but sorted my life out thankfully
@Ali Ní Dhomhnaill: Whether or not you disagree with his comments, calling somebody a ‘fool’ whilst incorrectly spelling the word ‘You’re’ shows that perhaps he’s not the only ‘fool’.
@Lovely weather: look up the dictionary, I think you will find “fool” is the correct spelling
@Lovely weather: “fool”noun.
a silly or stupid person; a person who lacks judgment or sense.
@Ali Ní Dhomhnaill: nah I expect their parents to get their acts together like most people in society.. My heart goes out to the children that was never my point… Oh and thank you for following my posts
@Ali Ní Dhomhnaill: he said “whilst incorrectly spelling the word “you’re”" not fool…
@Sharon Fernandes: even so the point about the definition whether made intentionally or not would still stand.that is a fool being a person without judgement or sense not a person who makes minor grammatical errors
If they’re anything like Erica Fleming and Co, they’ll laugh at shoebox 2nd hand presents.
If they’re not paying rent, then they are wealthier than the people the chuggers target.
You’re being fooled.
Don’t waste your money on these “charities”, donate to Bóthar or something.
@T Beckett is back: I think ICHH is actually one of the few good charities that has scaled without spending a ton of exec salaries etc. I think all their people are volunteers without pay. I like that they publish full audited accounts rather than ‘annual reports’ with cherry-picked information like most charities too.
One of the only ones I’ve donated to with how bad most Irish charities are with frivilous spending and mismanagement.
@T Beckett is back: I grew up in a shit hole a real bad bad shit hole.My first memory of fear was maybe 10 cops with sub machine guns on the shared balcony trying to get the lads who just robbed a jewellers.I always remembers this. Personally I wouldn’t ever give to Charities as the people who need it don’t get it the people who don’t need it demand it. Your all being taken for a ride. Charity begins at home.
I don’t understood a family being homeless in Dublin.
I commute from the midlands to Dublin for work (can’t afford to live in Dublin) and we(we have a young child) live on one civil service income.
Great idea. Bridges of hope are another group helping the homeless. Every Saturday night in the City Centre giving clothes and food. A Christmas dinner for homeless people and families in emergency accommodation will be held by them on Christmas
Excellent homeless charity!Some schools give out backpacks with essential items also& it’s great to see compassionate people including children.
The way some commentators here,often under pseudonyms, talk about fellow human beings in desperate stressful circumstances is truly disgusting and shameful!
have your say